“White Tiger” is a Russian movie
that was the nation’s selection for the 85th Academy Awards. It did
not make the cut. It was produced,
directed, and co-written by Karen Shakhnazarov (a male, by the way). The source material was a novella by Ilya
Boyashov. The movie is set during the
Great Patriotic War against Nazi Germany.
It is the summer of 1943 and a
nearly dead tank driver is pulled out of a destroyed tank and taken to the
hospital with 90% burns. He makes an
amazing recovery, but he has amnesia. He
is given the name Naydanev which means “found”.
He finds that he has the ability to speak to tanks. He is the “tank whisperer”. His goal (obsession) is to get even with a
mystical German tank called the “White Tiger”.
He thinks this demon destroyed his tank, and a crap load of others. Naydenev is supposedly given a super tank but
to tell the truth it doesn’t look any different than a regular T-34. He sets up an ambush, but the White Tiger
escapes into a swamp. Later, after it
singlehandedly decimates a Soviet tank assault, it escapes into a fog. Mother Nature seems to be a Nazi. Eventually Naydenev gets his duel and a
village takes the brunt of it. The movie
ends with Adolf Hitler ranting about war being the natural human state.
The Russians have made some good
war movies. “9th Company” and
“The Fortress of War” come to mind.
Unfortunately, “White Tiger” is not one of the better ones. It starts with an intriguing premise. But instead of going down the surer route of
steering toward horror territory, it decides to get all metaphorical on
us. As best I can figure, the White
Tiger represents war and Naydanev is the desire to end it. I could be wrong and the screenwriters could
have just been hacks. I do know that by
the end of the film, it is easier to make a case for Naydanev being bat s*** crazy than believe that he is some avenging angel. The whole movie is perplexing. I don't think intentionally. It might have worked as a camp fest, but Shakhnazarov
appears to have taken the material seriously.
For that reason, the combat is not over the top. The White Tiger is pretty awesome, but not
even close to invulnerable. In fact, it
does a lot of running away in the movie.
I can only imagine what the South Korean film industry could have done
with the premise. There is nothing about
the movie that takes your mind off the script flaws. Vertkov is not the Russian Brad Pitt. The real star is the White Tiger. We don’t get to see its interior, but
Naydanev’s tank’s interior is appropriately gritty and cramped. There is some POV from the interior and
overall the cinematography is fine. It
could have been a much better movie.
Pity. What a waste of a great
title.
GRADE = F
Totally agree with you. Yes, the White Tiger is a metaphor because Naydanev says something along the lines of "it will always be out there" right before the whole Hitler montage. Somewhere on YouTube I saw a comment that said this was an awesome "tank" movie. Fury had promise and blew it...so far an awesome tank movie has not been made.
ReplyDeleteI think that the original Sahara from 1843 was good, you should check it out if you have not.
DeleteTotally disagree. I really enjoyed this movie tremendously and it's probably one of the top five war movies ever seen. But if you prefer more down-to-earth fare, I can see how you wouldn't like this. It's a fantasy film first and foremost, and a war movie second.
ReplyDeleteI get it. Maybe I should watch it again.
DeleteYou are right, it is a metaphor and metaphors are not for viewing. PS. if you really want to see a 'F' movie, let me recommend T-34 and, as a bonus, a combination Bollywood/war movie called Border. Both do have tanks in them but T-34 makes Hogan's Heroes look like Saving Private Ryan and Border, well. I don't know. If you hate anyona and their birthday is approacing...
ReplyDeleteI found T-34 entertaining, but Border is the worst movie I saw last year. It is terrible!
Delete