Friday, November 20, 2026

SOUTH PACIFIC (1958)

 


            Okay. I know what you are thinking – “what the hell is Kevin doing reviewing a musical?” Yuck. Well, in my defense I would not have watched it if I could not argue it is a war movie. The musical / war genre is probably the sparsest hybrid of war movies. The recent “Drummer Boy” is a rare example of telling a war story with songs. It’s certainly more of a war movie than “South Pacific”, but “South Pacific” is set in wartime and has military characters. It can best be described as a military movie and I count those. If you don’t, I have no problem with that.

            “South Pacific” began as a Rogers and Hammerstein Broadway musical. It was not their first to go from stage to screen. “Oklahoma” and “Carousel” were the first. The play was based on James Michener’s collection of short stories entitled Tales of the Southwest Pacific. Joshua Logan had written the play and he directed the movie. Logan had served in the Army in WWII in public relations and intelligence. He was responsible for “jeep shows” that brought entertainers close to the front lines. Logan had directed Broadway shows before the war and after. He directed two war movies – “Mister Roberts” and “Ensign Pulver”. Only Juanita Hall reprised her role from the play, but she was dubbed for the movie. Of the main characters, only Mitzi Gaynor did her own singing. Gaynor replaced Mary Martin after Ezio Pinza died before filming. Rogers did not want to match her with a new leading man. He was replaced by Rossano Brazzi. Doris Day was considered, but Rogers thought she did not have enough range. Elizabeth Taylor failed an audition when she froze in front of Rogers. Mitzi Gaynor was the third choice.

            The movie was shot on the Hawaiian island of Kauai. The US Navy cooperated with landing craft, trucks, jeeps, planes, and uniforms. This helped with the budget. The movie was a big hit and was Rogers and Hammerstein’s biggest hit until “Sound of Music” seven years later. It was very popular in Great Britain where it played in one London theater for four and a half years!  It made more than its cost in just that one theater. The critics were not as enamored as the public. It did get one Oscar for Best Sound and was nominated for Music and Cinematography. The cinematography was controversial due to the use of color filters for the musical numbers. Logan meant them to stand apart from the other scenes, but it ended up being so jarring that Logan wished he had not gone that route. It was nominated for Golden Globes for Best Musical or Comedy and Gaynor was nominated for Best Actress.

            The movie opens on an unidentified island in the Pacific in 1943. Although the island is not in a war zone, apparently it needs a Seabees unit to construct something. They aren’t going to do much, other than sing. The main romance is between Emile (Brazzi), a French planter, and Nellie (Gaynor) who is a nurse. A Marine Lt. Cable (John Kerr) arrives and wants Emile to help him set up a coastwatcher station on a Japanese occupied island. At first, Emile does not want to risk his life and his future with Nell. That will change, of course. Meanwhile, a second romance is brewing between Cable and Lait, an island girl on the idyllic Bali Hai. Lait happens to be the daughter of the local black marketeer Bloody Mary (Hall). Both romances are going to run into typical romance hurdles. Unbelievably, this all leads to a combat scene! Tbose are F6Fs. Hooray for naval cooperation. Not typically, one of the main characters is killed. But don’t worry, the ending is sealed with a kiss.

            If you are into Broadway musicals, “South Pacific” won’t disappoint. And if you want to watch a war musical that actually has shots fired, you’ll probably like it. It does not rise to the level of the best war musical, “Oh! What a Lovely War”, but it is not a mushy mess. Despite the added action, the movie is rated less than the play mostly because the pairing of Pinza/Martin was better vocally than Brazzi/Gaynor. The dubbing is seamless, so you won’t know which are faking it. Unless you read this review first. All sixteen songs are from the play and you get a bonus tune. Oddly, for a romance musical, there are no duets with Brazzi/Gayner. The soundtrack includes three famous songs: “Bali Ha’i”, “I’m Gonna to Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair”, and “Some Enchanted Evening (#28 on AFI’s 100 greatest movie song). Commendably, Rogers and Hammerstein refused to omit the controversial “You’ve Got to Be Carefully Taught” which posits that racism is not genetic. The film did not play in some theaters in the South. We’ve come a long way. Or have we.

            The acting is not as broad as in your average musical. Other than the Seabees prancing around. Unfortunately, Brazzi is a dud. Perhaps because he was upset that he was not worthy of singing for himself. Howard Keel, Charles Boyer, and Fernando Lamas were considered for the role and any of the three would have been better. Gaynor is better as an actress and her voice is fine. Luther, the leader of the Seabees, is played by Ray Walston (famous for “My Favorite Martian”). You will be impressed with his singing. He is not dubbed. Take that, Brazzi.

            As a musical romance, “South Pacific” is one of the greatest. However, since this is a war movie review, I’ll tell my followers that you should watch it as part of your cinema bucket list, but not in your effort to see all the great war movies. As a war movie, it is average. 

GRADE = C



Saturday, November 14, 2026

DRUMMER BOY (2026)

 

            “Drummer Boy” is a war musical from Angel Studios. The studio is famous for its Christian-themed movies. This is its third war movie after “Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Spy, Assassin ” and “Young Washington” (which was not overtly religious). This is its second American Revolution movie to coincide with the 250th Anniversary of American Independence. Besides being a patriotic movie, it also could be classified as a Christmas movie. Three of the songs are classic Christmas songs. It was directed by Ben and Joel David Smallbone. Joel is part of the duo For King and Country. That Christian rock band provided four songs on the soundtrack. The film was in development since 2019. It was filmed in Ireland and had a budget of $10 million. It looks like it will make a profit. Critics have been lukewarm, but audiences are more enthusiastic, especially viewers who came to see a Christian movie.

            The movie opens with two British families sailing for the 13 Colonies near the end of the French and Indian War. Nathaniel Clem (Ioan Gruffudd) is a British officer. His wife Rachel (Melora Hardin) and her sons Jeremiah (Joel David Smallbone) and Ben (Lucas Leach) will own a grain mill in Kingston, New York. Also on board are Lord Balfour (Charles Esten) and his daughter Elizabeth (Beth Easdown). Their slave Emmalin (India Brown) is in love with Jeremiah since their childhood. The ship duels with a French warship and then the movie jumps twelve years to 1775. Word of Lexington and Concord divides the inhabitants of Kingston. Jeremiah joins Lord Balfour’s regiment of Redcoats partly because he is wooing his daughter. Ben joins the Continental Army because he believes in FREEDOM! Because he is crippled, he becomes a drummer boy. He is just a teenager, but he has a real knack for drumming. Ben’s regiment is led by Maj. Ambrose (Iain Glen). This regiment is going to spend the war fighting with Balfour’s regiment. Which, of course, means the two brothers will face off. A subplot has Emmalin writing love letters to Jeremiah pretending to be Elizabeth.

            The trailer underplays how much singing is in the movie. There are 14 times the cast breaks into song. These moments are similar to if you were attending a musical play. Five of those songs are religious. If you were to go see this movie without being aware that it is a musical, you might be distracted by the musical numbers. However, if you are forewarned, the musical interludes are not overly cringey. Just don’t expect “Hamilton” quality. The actors are decent singers and Joel Smallbone is a professional, so you won’t be sticking your fingers in your ears. Some of the songs intercut between different characters in different places. The lip-synching is not a problem. The movie might put you in the Christmas spirit with renditions of “Oh Come All Ye Faithful”, “Oh Come, Oh Come Emmanuel”, and “Little Drummer Boy”, of course.

            Besides the religious songs, Christianity pops up consistently throughout. At this point, if you know about Angel Studios, you will easily guess it was produced by that studio. I commend the Smallbones for bringing a patriotic musical to the screen in the sesquicentennial year. The celebration has been mostly tepid, so “Drummer Boy” is a slight upgrade from most of the entertainment. However, I am not reviewing it as patriotic fare. This is a war movie review.

            As a war movie, “Drummer Boy” is embarrassing. I am not referring to soldiers breaking into song. It has cliché characters and predictable developments. Lord Balfour and his daughter are caricature villains. The brother versus brother template is hardly original. The only question is whether the two will reconcile or not. It will be apparent early which path the movie is taking. The love triangle also has a predictable outcome, but it’s a bit more off the beaten path. The plot manages to make slavery part of the equation. It’s heavy-handed as you would expect from a 21st Century movie about the American Revolution. And since it is an American movie, don’t expect Balfour to be in favor of freedom (which the Brits actually were, moreso than the Americans).

            The biggest problem is when you focus on whether it is a good war movie, it has a lot of silliness in it. The regiment versus regiment idea brings too much attention to the low budget. A regiment in the Revolutionary War had around 600 men. The two in this movie have about 20. The movie gives no big picture. It gives the impression that the war in the Kingston area was just two regiments fighting. And the battles (actually skirmishes) are poorly rendered. It does not appear reeanctors were used. There is an encounter where the Continentals target a bridge held by Balfour’s men. The plan is ruined by Ben freezing and not playing his drum, as though Maj. Ambrose could not have just yelled “Charge!” And then a Redcoat accidentally drops a torch (in broad daylight) which lands in gunpowder stored under the bridge. EXPLOSION! Collapse! Hooray for Hollywood! This is golden compared to the last skirmish which has to be one of the most laughable combat scenes I have ever seen. And it throws in my least favorite Christmas song like a rotten cherry on top.

            I recently started a YouTube channel with short videos on famous boy soldiers or units of boy soldiers. One of the first shorts was on Johnny Clem, the most famous drummer boy in American History. Clem fought in the Civil War, but there were drummer boys in the Revolutionary War also. I really looked forward to seeing “Drummer Boy” in the theater, even after I learned it was a musical. Don’t let this review stop you from seeing it. If you like Christian themed musicals. However, if are more of a pure war movie fan, you’ve been warned.

GRADE  =  D






Sunday, November 8, 2026

JIMMY (2026)


            “Jimmy” is a biopic of Jimmy Stewart that focuses on his role in WWII. It was directed by Aaron Burns who is noted for his faith-based films. It cost $14 million. The movie features a cameo from Karolyn Grimes who played Zuzu Bailey in “It’s a Wonderful Life.” One of the executive producers was Stewart’s daughter Kelly Stewart Harcourt. She also has a cameo. Her involvement means the family was pleased with the film. And not upset with the historical license.

            The film is bookended by the making of “It’s a Wonderful Life”. Five years earlier, Jimmy Stewart (KJ Apa) is coming off a Best Actor Oscar for “The Philadelphia Story”. He receives a draft notice and when he informs Louis B. Mayer (Jason Alexander) of MGM, Mayer tells his moneymaker that he’ll take care of it. Surprise, Jimmy wants to serve. He enlists in the Army Air Corps as a B-24 Liberator bomber pilot. The movie foregoes the traditional training sequence and sends Stewart’s bomber group across the Atlantic to Great Britain. They lose a bomber to enemy fire during the trip. Danger established. On his first mission, his bomber is hit by flak, but Jimmy pulls it out of a death dive and resumes his position in the formation. This is a clue that the screenwriter is going to be using the historical license excuse.

            Stewart will end up flying 20 missions, but the movie covers only a few. This is because it has to find time for Jimmy’s romance with an upper-class British woman. Julia (Kara Kilmer) will have to deal with her beau’s increasing PTSD. Jimmy returns home in 1945 and is not mentally ready to return to acting. His friend, director Frank Kapra (Max Casella) talks him into making “It’s a Wonderful Life”. It’s not going to be like get back  on a bike.

            Two minutes into the movie, I wrote in my notes “hokey?” The next two hours proved the answer to that question was a resounding “yes!” However, I don’t think that will be a dealbreaker for most people who go to see this movie. BTW based on the audience I saw it with, those people will be mostly the elderly. I am in that demographic, but I am also a hardcore war movie fanatic. So, if you are reading this review, I feel you will probably find it hokey. For instance, when Jimmy’s co-pilot shows him a picture of his girlfriend, I don’t think many of my fellow audience members knew he was dead meat. But all my readers will know it. I don’t know if the screenwriter doesn’t know this cliché or he didn’t think his core audience would know it. And part of the hokeyness are the religious moments in the film. The movie does not jam Christianity down the viewers’ throats, but it is not subtle either.

            Jimmy Stewart is one of my favorite actors and he is one of my favorite historical figures. And not to overuse the word hokey, it does fit his personality and many of the characters he played. Apa does a good job impersonating him. If you haven’t seen many of Stewart’s movies, you might find the performance to be a bit hammy. It doesn’t help that the rest of the cast thinks they are in a play. Alexander plays the caricature of a villainous Hollywood studio boss. Rob Riggle is wooden as the gruff bomber boss. Stewart’s crew is all “aww shucks”. It was a poor decision to use Hedda Hopper, the gossip columnist, as a framing device. Her appearances in the narrative are annoying.

            The film suffers from one of the biggest problems of the series “Masters of the Air”. There is not enough time spent on missions. There is just enough to show that the CGI is average and not distractingly bad. The interior scenes in the bomber are embarrassingly unrealistic. There is little that will inform you about the air war. There is one poignant loss, but the movie only implies the high level of losses by having a pilot complain that nobody cares. Instead of the more obvious “how the hell do they expect us to get to 30 missions?!” Jimmy certainly cares. Too much, as Patton would have sniffed. He ends up with justifiable PTSD which creates the template for the postwar scenes. This is a bit trite, but does accurately reflect Stewart’s rough road after the war.

            A movie like “Jimmy” has to be judged partly on its adherence to history and realism. I read a book about Stewart’s WWII experiences, but that was year’s ago so I was not sure what parts were accurate. “Jimmy” is the kind of movie where I am watching and constantly saying to myself, “That can’t possibly be true.” I’m often surprised that some of the most unlikely plot developments are actually true. This is not the case in this movie. However, if you want to see the movie, don’t read beyond this point and don’t look at the grade because it is one letter lower because of veracity problems (as are pointed out in the historical accuracy section below).

            “Jimmy” is the kind of old school Hollywood film (actually closer to a Hallmark movie) that critics will sneer at but audiences will enjoy. It’s the only movie we will get about the most heroic actor that served in WWII so it will have to do. And if it gets people to dust off some of his movies that will be great because he is on the Mount Rushmore of American male actors.

 

GRADE  =  C-

 

HISTORICAL ACCURACY:  Louis B. Mayer did try to dissuade Stewart from enlisting and although the movie makes him into a villain, he certainly was right as far as MGM was concerned. Compare Stewart to other stars, like John Wayne, who dodged service for legitimate reasons. Stewart’s service is close to Clark Gable’s with Gable flying a few missions as a gunner, but mostly making films for the military. Stewart’s best friend, Henry Fonda, also enlisted and served in the Navy. Stewart was the earliest big star to enlist and significantly did it 8 months before Pearl Harbor. The film oddly does not cover the lengths Stewart went to get in. He failed the first physical because he was underweight at 6’3”, but only 138 pounds. He had to eat a special diet to get to the weight for the second attempt. The movie does not indicate that he was an accomplished pilot already. He spent the first year making films, including “Winning Your Wings” which is mentioned in the movie. He also trained other pilots. He pushed hard for an overseas assignment which definitely showed he was a patriot. No bombers were lost on the transatlantic trip. The movie bizarrely describes the trip as “over the German-controlled North Atlantic”. The implication that a bomber was shot down by a u-boat is laughable. The first mission was to a u-boat facility, but the damaging of his bomber and rejoining the formation did not happen. He did have a mission where they had engine trouble and had to return to base. The bomber that took its place as leader was shot down with the loss of the crew. Stewart suffered from survivor’s guilt which contributed to his PTSD.  The mission where he tried to convince another squadron that it was taking the wrong route is the closest the movie comes to the truth. Stewart did make the decision to follow with his squadron to support the idiot who was way off in his navigation. They did pass over Paris. This was the mission which earned him the Distinguished Flying Cross. He did get promoted to Major and then Colonel, making him a very rare private to colonel in four years. The crew was fictionalized. He did not have a set bomber or crew. He flew on various bombers, often as mission leader in the co-pilot’s chair. There was no incident where a bomber he had flown in crashed when he had not been able to pilot it. There was an incident where his flight engineer went AWOL, so his bomber had to stay home. The bomber that took its place was shot down. This was additional survivor’s guilt. The movie has Stewart waiting for his bomber to come back. It would have been more appropriate to stick to the truth of the stressful times Stewart waited for his group to return. In one raid, the group lost 13 of 25  bombers. He did have a mission where flak blew a hole in the floor of the cockpit. When he returned to America, he did go through a time when he thought about giving up Hollywood to work in his father’s store. It is true that Frank Capra (who spent the war making the acclaimed “Why We Fight” documentaries) convinced him to make “It’s a Wonderful Life”. It was both their first films after the war. The movie correctly mentions that the movie was not a hit. Stewart did have a tough time making the film and he did channel some of his PTSD into his best performance. He received an Oscar nomination for it.

            The movie lays religion on a bit thick, but it is true that Stewart was a religious man. His father did give him a pocket Bible/Psalms. As far as his romances, he did not propose to Ginger Rogers. They had dated a while, but that was in 1935. The Julia character stands in for the mysterious British woman who he dated for a while. He never revealed who she was.






Friday, November 6, 2026

PRIMITIVE WAR (2025)

 

            “Primitive War’ is a war horror movie directed by Luke Sparke. He brought Ethan Peltus’ novel Primitive War: Opiate Undertow to the screen. He ended up co-producing it because the Hollywood studios did not want to back a Jurassic Park clone. Sparke had to raise the money himself. The picture had a $7 million budget, but made only $1.2 million at the box office. A sequel is being planned for 2027.

            The movie is set in Vietnam in 1968. It opens with an American Green Beret squad being wiped out on a dark and stormy night by dinosaurs.  Col. Jericho (Jeremy Piven) calls upon a LRRP (long range patrol) unit to locate the Green Berets. They, of course, are not aware they will be encountering dinosaurs. They are cocky and unconcerned. It will be a piece of cake. Too bad “Predator” had not come out yet. The team is led by Sgt. Baker (Ryan Kwanten) and has seven members. They are dropped off in the jungle by Huey helicopters. Soon after, they find a giant animal footprint, a giant feather, and a huge pile of shit. Hmm. Perhaps there is more than Viet Cong and North Vietnamese in the jungle. Actually, there is dinosaurs, but also a Soviet group tracking them. It is led by Gen. Borodin (Jeremy Taylor). He is in Vietnam heading a project to create a particle collider that will transport Soviet soldiers to anywhere in the world. Guess what it accidentally transported from the distant past. In case you are interested in the science behind this, it's called "deextinction". I doubt they had a scientific advisor on set. Baker and his boys find out about this nefarious project from a sexy Soviet paleontologist named Sofia (Tricia Helfer, using an atrocious Russian accent). She has this funny notion that they should shut down the project in order to save the world. What ensues is a lot of running through the jungle (some of it to the Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Run Through the Jungle"). The Vulture Squad has to escape dinosaurs and firefights with the commies. If you think most of Baker’s squad will survive, you haven’t seen movies like this. Imagine “The Dirty Dozen” with dinosaurs.

            This is a fun movie. If you like dinosaurs, Cold War good versus evil, and gore. Lots of gore. Considering its low budget, the CGi dinosaurs are amazing. 32 years after “Jurassic Park” awed us, a dinosaur-loving director can make a low budget movie which has dinosaurs that look as realistic as a movie that had a $60 million budget. There are a variety of dinosaurs including Utahraptors, Tyrannus Rex’s, Brontosaurus’ and Pterodactyls. The movie does feel like it was shot in Jurassic Park.

            There is not much character development, other than Baker and Sofia. The squad is a typically heterogenous cinematic unit. The men are all cliches. The wiseass, the stressed out, the black with a machete, the fucking new guy. Baker is stereotyped, but he is well-played by Kwanton. He and Helfer have some chemistry. Their relationship breaks no new ground as the two start off disliking each other. This will change, of course. The rest of the cast is competent. Oddly, the weak link is Piven.

            The movie is chock full of action which builds to a final ten minutes of mayhem. Unlike “Jurassic Park”, it is not for children. The violence is bloody. It borders on combat porn, but at least each of the main character deaths are varied. Kudos to the screenwriters for being creative. Some of the action is pumped up by some classic hits like “Fortunate Son” (over the opening credits) “Time Has Come Today”. “Revolution Road”, and “Give Me Some Lovin’”.

            “Primitive War” is one of the better war horror movies. It was not on my list of the ten best , but that was because I had not seen it at the time. I would put it at around #5 on an updated list. It is better than it has any reason to be. Don’t expect anything new if you have seen a few “rescue behind the lines” movies. Throwing in realistic looking dinosaur separates it from all the other movies in that subgenre.

GRADE  =  B