Showing posts with label Anne Frank. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anne Frank. Show all posts

Thursday, June 12, 2025

The Diary of Anne Frank (1959)


 


 
               Today is Anne Frank Day because she received her diary as a gift for her 13th birthday on June 12, 1942. Her father, who was the only one of her family to survive their stay in concentration camps, published the diary in 1947 and it instantly became a best-seller. In 1955, a Broadway play based on the diary was a big hit. The playwrights, Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett, wrote the screenplay. George Stevens (“Gunga Din”) was chosen to direct. He was a good choice partly because during WWII he was a major in the Army Signal Corps. He had enlisted after seeing the infamous Nazi propaganda film “Triumph of the Will”. He and his crew filmed in Normandy after the D-Day invasion. His unit produced the only color footage of the war in Europe. He followed the American army all the way to the Elbe River. He reached Dachau death camp two days after it was liberated. He filmed at other concentration camps and then created the documentary “The Nazi Plan”. It was used at the Nuremberg Trials. He wanted Audrey Hepburn for the lead role because she looked a lot like Anne. She declined because she felt she was old at 30. She also was uncomfortable about bringing back memories from her life in the Netherlands during the war. Stevens auditioned thousands of young women and chose a 17-year-old model named Millie Perkins. Shelley Winters sought the part of Petronella van Daan. She was twenty years younger than Petranella. She gained 30 pounds for the role and lost 25 during the shoot. Stevens was determined to make a realistic and emotional picture. An exact replica of the three story building was constructed in a large sound stage. He kept the temperature on set appropriate for the time of year that was being filmed. This meant the actors were freezing during the winter scenes. The exterior scenes were filmed on location in Amsterdam. Otto Frank and Johannes Kleiman were technical advisers. The movie was a modest hit and was nominated for Academy Awards for Best Picture, Director, Costume Design, and Score. It won for Best Supporting Actress (Shelley Winters who donated here Oscar to the Anne Frank Museum where it is still on display), Art Direction, and Cinematography. Winning three Oscars when “Ben Hur” dominated the awards was quite an accomplishment. It helped that they were giving separate awards for black/white and color. It was rated the 18th greatest inspirational movies for AFIs 100 Years…100 Cheers.

               The movie uses a flashforward introduction as Otto Frank (Joseph Schildkraut reprising his Broadway role) visits the building after the war. Miep (Dodie Heath), the Gentile woman who helped hide the family, presents him with the diary which she and Mr. Kraler (Douglas Spencer) have saved. The film flashes back to July, 1942 when the Franks and the van Daans take up residence in the attic above the spice factory. Otto goes over the rules which include no noise during the daytime hours. I wonder if students will watch the movie today and pass out when they learn Anne would read for ten hours a day. She finished “A Tale of Two Cities” in one day. There is dysfunction between the two families mostly because of eight different personalities living in such a claustrophic and stressful situation. Anne is about the same age as Peter van Daan and they are not exactly Romeo and Juliet, but they gradually develop feelings for each other. Anne is a typical teenage girl as evidenced by her diary. She idolizes her father and tries her mother’s patience. The seven show their humanity by agreeing to take in Miep’s Jewish dentist Alfred Dussel (Ed Wynn). He adds more dysfunction. There are some edge of your seat moments because most viewers don’t know how or when they were caught. This adds suspense to the movie. At one point a burglar breaks into the factory and the cops come. Later, German Gestapo agents search the bottom two floors. There is an excellent scene where they endure a bombing raid. This is the one scene that the play could not recreate.

               Stevens did a great job bringing the diary to film. Screenwriters Goodrich and Hackett won a Pulitzer Prize for their play so Stevens had an excellent script to work from. The screenplay incorporates diary entries which are narrated by Anne. The cinematography deservedly won an Oscar for William Mellor. The camera would move from floor to floor. The lighting shines appropriate for an ill-lit attic. The only technical weakness is the sappy score. The cast is great. They all behave realistically. The movie does not make them heroes. They are typical people thrown into a terrifying situation. You will wonder if you could have survived what they survived. Until that fateful day. The movie answers the question of who ratted them out by choosing the burglar as the villain. It is still unclear if this is correct. Millie Perkins is surprisingly effective in her first acting role. She had no training as Stevens picked  her after seeing her photo and convincing her to audition. She was a better choice than Hepburn, so that worked out well.

               Obviously, the movie is a must-see which means I’m pretty embarrassed that it took me so long to see it. The film is inspiring, but very sad. That is as it should be. It is a great companion to the book and follows the book carefully. There are no Hollywood embellishments. What we do get is some Hollywood expansion of the story. Fans of the book might not have had an idea of the role that Miep and Kraler played in their valiant attempt to save members of a different race/religion. Would you have risked your life like they did? God help us because that question may be in our future.

P.S. I completed my 100 Best War Movies list before I saw this movie. I know, I know. Mea culpa. It does belong in the top 100.

GRADE = A


 

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

A Small Light (2023)

 

            “A Small Light” is a limited series that first appeared on National Geographic and is now playing on Netflix.  It is based on the book “Anne Frank Remembered”  The Story of the Woman Who Helped to Hide the Frank Family” which was published in 1987.  The title comes from a statement by Hermine “Mieps” Gies:  “I don’t like being called a hero because no one should ever think you have to be special to help others.  Even an ordinary secretary, housewife, or teenager can turn on a small light in a dark room.”  It has been nominated for Critics Choice awards for Best Limited Series, Best Actress in a Limited Series or Made for TV Movie (Bel Powley), and Best Actor in a Limited Series or Made for TV Movie (Liev Schrieber).

            The series opens in Amsterdam in July, 1942.  Miep Gies (Powley) gets Margot Frank through a German checkpoint even though Margot does not have her identification papers.  A flashback to 1933 shows her getting hired as Otto Frank’s secretary.  Mr. Frank’s company makes pectin and spices.  Otto (Live Schreiber) and Miep bond over being refugees.  Miep was adopted by a Dutch family.  She is feisty and fun-loving, but has to grow up when the German army marches into Amsterdam in May, 1940.  She doesn’t think twice when Mr. Frank asks her to help hide them.  He warns her it will be dangerous, but she is not deterred.  The family and some other Jews hide in the upstairs of Mr. Frank’s business.  Miep gets married to Jan (Joe Cole).  He gets recruited to the Dutch resistance, so he has his own risk-taking going on.  He helps with hiding Jews and making illegal ration cards so they can get food.  Miep and several other employees keep the business running and help with the hiding.  Miep befriends Anne and knows she is keeping a diary.  On August 4, 1944, the Gestapo arrives. 

            Everyone knows the Anne Frank story.  Her diary is one of the most famous books in history.  And it was made into “The Diary of Anne Frank” in 1959.  “A Small Light” gives a different perspective of the tragedy.  It focuses on Miep Gies, instead of Anne.  That would be inexcusable if Anne’s story had not already been told well.  And Miep’s story needed to be told.  Not to take away from the victims of the Holocaust, but there were brave Gentiles who risked their lives to help some of them.  Miep and Jan fall into that group.  The movie does an admirable job combining the story of the Frank family and the others with that of their Dutch friends.  It also adds in a resistance subplot focusing on Jan.

            The cast is outstanding, especially Bel Powley.  She starts as a party girl who is nagged by her adoptive parents to grow up and get a job.  Little does she know that meeting Otto Frank will change her life and bring our the heroine in her.  Her relationship with Otto is at the center of the movie.  She also interacts with Anne (Billie Boullet) more than with any of the others.  The series realistically portrays her as a teenage girl.  Which means she was something of a pain in the ass.  The rest of the hiders are peripheral to the story.  Some of the dysfunction is shown.  These were people thrown together in an cramped attic.  The series makes you wonder why it took so long to find them.  Their noise discipline was not good.  The series does not take a stand on who tipped off the Nazis and it does not follow them in captivity.  Only Otto returns to thank Miep for all she did.  And to receive the diary that she saved.

            How accurate is it?  Miep did get a job after an interview with Otto.  After working for him for years, the Frank family was forced to go into hiding when Margot got an order to report to a work camp.  Otto did ask Miep to help them and she agreed immediately.  The checkpoint scene did not occur, but Miep did bicycle with Margot to the hiding place.  It was during a rain storm so no one was suspicious of a Jew riding an illegal bike.  The sets used for the building and the secret annex were based on the actual locale.  Johan did build a bookcase to cover the door to the annex.  Jan was a member of the resistance and did things like providing illegal ration books and helping hide people.  He never talked about his resistance activities so the series filled in the gaps.  The couple did hide an anti-Nazi college student named Kuno van der Horst.  Miep’s friend Tess is fictional.  She represents the Dutch who cooperated with the Nazis.  The arrest was accurate.  The series does not assign blame, but Miep, in an interview, did not think the leading suspect (Willem van Maaren) was guilty.  Miep did find the diary and kept it for Anne.  She did not read it and she later said that was lucky because if she had she would have burned it because it had names of people who would have been arrested.  The movie shortchanges the actions of Bep Voskuiul, who was with Miep when they found the diary.  Much of what Miep did, Bep also did, but the series kept it simpler.  Miep did go to SS headquarters in an attempt to get them freed.  She did get questioned by an agent that turned out to be from her hometown of Vienna and because of that he let her go.  She did turn over the diary to Otto after the war. 

GRADE  =  B

There was a documentary made about Miep called “Anne Frank Remembered” (1995).