“Decision Before Dawn” is a black and white film
directed by Anatole Litvak. He filmed in
post-war Germany for the ambiance provided by rubble. It was based on a novel
by George Howe entitled Call It Treason which was inspired by the fact
that the British and Americans used captured Germans as counterintelligence
agents in the last months of the war.
These prisoners of war had various motives for helping. The credits claimed that the movie was based
on a true story with the names changed.
The movie was a surprise nominee for Best Picture. Litvak thanked the U.S. Armed Forces and the
French Army for cooperation.
A narrator (Richard Basehart): “Why does a spy risk his life – if he wins,
he’s ignored. If he loses, he’s
shot.” The quote is backed by a
realistic firing squad execution. The
movie is set in Germany in December, 1944.
Col. Devlin (Gary Merrill) is recruiting German prisoners for spying
behind enemy lines. After a friend is
“court-martialed” and killed by hard core Nazis for pessimism, a young soldier
nicknamed “Happy” volunteers. His
motivation is the Germans have lost the war and his aid will shorten the war
and free him sooner. On the other end of
the spectrum is “Tiger” who is a cynic who is in it for personal gain. The duo are paired off with a skeptical Lt.
Rennick (Basehart) for a crucial mission.
Rennick and Tiger will make contact with a German general who wants to
defect. Meanwhile, Happy will scout
enemy troop dispositions on his own.
The movie concentrates on Happy’s odyssey (which is
Homeric) and his interaction with a variety of Germans. They range from defeatists to die-hards. Some are sympathetically portrayed. In his guise of a travelling German medic,
Happy gets tabbed with serving a general.
The general is a good German common to Cold War depictions of German
generals in cinema. Instead of killing
him, Happy saves his life when he has a heart attack. This interlude provides him with the valuable
intelligence that he sought and now it’s just a matter of returning. He meets up with Rennick and Tiger in a safe
house in Mannheim. Only one will survive
the return trip.
“Decision Before Dawn” is a different take on the
closing months of the war in Europe.
Enough time had passed to allow a more nuanced depiction of the German
people in those chaotic days when some realized the war was hopeless and others
wanted to continue the fight to the bitter end.
It was one of the first war movie to concentrate on the dissenters
rather than the Nazis. Coincidentally, "The Desert Fox" was released the same year.
Not only are the characters realistic, but the locales are amazing. Six years after the war there were still
areas of Germany that were war damaged.
The acting is great.
Basehart is an underrated actor and he is matched by Blech (who so
memorably played Pluskat in “The Longest Day”) and Werner. Both were German veterans and ironically, the
date that the Happy is captured (Dec. 8, 1944) was the exact date that Werner
deserted. The dialogue they are given is
a cut above the usual WWII movie. The
screenplay is thought-provoking and unpredictable. The hero is a traitor! He is not “just another kraut” as a G.I.
refers to him.
I can’t recall how this movie showed up on my radar screen. I had never heard of it and it
is not well known (in spite of its Best Picture nomination). I also had never given much thought to the
use of German prisoners to spy on Nazi Germany.
The movie does an excellent job shedding light on that obscure program. I like it when a war movie exposes the public
to a little known aspect of history and does it in an entertaining and accurate
way. It reminded me of one of the first
forgotten gems I posted on when I started my blog – "Time Limit". That movie also starred Richard Basehart and
dealt with collaboration.
Forgotten gem?
Yes. This movie deserves to be
seen.
Grade =
B
I first saw "Decision Before Dawn" on NBC Saturday Night at The Movies over 50 years ago. NBC had bought 20th Century Fox films and used them for the first ever prime time showing of movies. "The Desert Fox" was also shown by NBC Saturday Night at The Movies about this time.
ReplyDeleteIt's been one of my favorites ever since. Filming it in the actual locations not long after the war is the film's strong point.
The novel it's based on, "Call It Treason," was written by George Howe, who was part of the unit sending the German POWs out on missions. The novel has more characters and internal monologues than a film can have. Peter Viertel, who wrote the screenplay, was also in this unit.
I want to read the book.
DeleteJust saw this movie. Great flick!
ReplyDeleteI found this movie to be a gripping and thought provoking depiction of a conflicted soldier who forages a new direction in his life, regardless of the misguided loyalties exhibited by various other players within his immediate sphere of operation. The American and German psyche is explored within a framework of chaos and necessity dictated by a devistating and all encompassing war. Werner provides a decidedly underplayed hero that adds layers of credibility to his character rather than the overblown macho American protagonist that usually accompanies Hollywood war movies. The scenes were all filmed on location where the war was actually waged, further enhancing the authenticity of this excellent drama. The supporting cast delivers a depth of social interplay that realistically depicts the strained interactions associated with life in a war torn country on the verge of collapse. Various messages can be derived from the story line because of the superb dialogue that captures the prevailing sentiments of the characters as they all attempt to survive amid the violent upheaval of war. The film starts out slow but builds to a menacingly active crescendo as Werner navigates his way through intense danger to complete his assigned mission. The more I see of this film, the more I appreciate its dramatic authencity.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you and with the comments above. This movie blew me away.
ReplyDelete1. Acting, as you say, is great. I've liked Blech everywhere I've seen him but I think this is the greatest role I've seen him play. If they could have expanded this into a miniseries it would be need to see him, and some of the other side characters, more fleshed out.
2. The spy action feels authentic and is nevertheless gripping. None of the spies are James Bond. Only their wits, their coolness under pressure and (in the last resort) their legs protect them from capture and death. And unlike a lot of other spy thrillers where spies and their handlers affect a sophisticated world-weariness but just look like jerks this film really shows how stressful and emotionally difficult this profession might be, at least for people with a conscience.
3. The depiction of Germany is amazing. Normally visiting World War II Germany is like going to Transylvania, except that the vampires are now dressed like Nazi aristocrats and the rest of the population are divided between monsters and victims. Here, most of the people look and talk like people, trying to get along. They do feel stereotypically German in behavior and speech (the accents are thankfully light but do a great job of conveying the idea of foreign speech - even the cadence of speech and the vocabulary will be very familiar to anyone who knows a native German speaker) but they act and react like human beings. Even the aristocratic general explains his motivations in hard but understandable terms. The Americans also played with great subtle touches of inexperience and moral self-righteousness but general good intentions. That also seems authentic.
Like the previous commenter, "dramatic authenticity" describes the feeling I got from this film. I do not know if the movie's depiction of the people and places of this time are accurate but it feels very right, and I would not be surprised to find out that it was closer to the actual experiences of the people of that time than most World War II movies covering the same subjects.
Thanks. Good stuff.
DeleteBrilliant film. I loved it. Never heard of it before ..it is just so different from the usual war film. It was laudable that it portrayed a German soldier as an honerable, decent man. Happy is the star of the film as far as i am concerned. A sensitive caring person caught up in the horrors of the 3rd Reich and the War. His encounters with other german citizens and soldiers shows the pain and suffering of those caught up in the maelstrom of the closing chapter of WW2.
ReplyDeleteExcellent analysis.. thank you. Watched this for the first time yesterday and was very impressed with the dialogue, the theme, acting and the direction. Definitely a lost gem. I've Been watching war movies and documentaries for 50 years and Decision Before Dawn is one of the very best
DeleteJust watched this. Excellent film, great acting, interesting story and informative... I didn't know they used pows to spy. Kept me on tenterhooks for much of it. Realistic and without the usual war film gore. Well worth watching
ReplyDeleteI would like to know about the real life "Happy" and his family.
ReplyDeleteHappy was caught, what happened to him? Was he killed by the Nazi?
ReplyDelete