Wednesday, March 25, 2020

TV SERIES: Das Boot (2018)




                        “Das Boot” is a miniseries that appeared on German TV.  It was eight episodes of about one hour each.  It was a sequel to the movie and is set about nine months later, in 1942.  The plot was based on Lothar-Gunther Buchheim’s novel and its sequel Die Festung.  It used the same non-diving replica used in “U-571”.

                        The series opens with a nifty visual of a dolphins swimming alongside a surfaced sub.  Suddenly a plane attacks, forcing a dive (“alarm!”) that leaves Capt. Wrangel (Stefan Konarske) on deck.  An American destroyer drops depth charges and the clichés click in.  The U-113 goes below crush depth, rivets pop and leaks cause flooding.  Close-ups show tension.  The series has hit the sea silent running.  It turns out that the U-113 is not the u-boat that will be the star.  That will be the U-612 which is a new boat that will be captained by a green Capt. Hoffman (Rick Okon).  He has daddy issues because his dad was a famous u-boat ace from WWI.  He wrote a book about it.  Hoffman has some big shoes to fill.  He won’t get any help from his exec Lt. Tennstedt (August Wittgenstein).  Naturally, they do not get along.  There is a “Run Silent, Run Deep” vibe.  Does any cinematic captain get along with his exec?

                        The other plot line involves the French Resistance.  An interpreter named Simone (Vicky Krieps) has arrived in La Rochelle and goes to work for the Gestapo.  Herr Forster (Tom Wlaschiha) takes a lust to her which will get complicated when Simone finds out her brother Frank (Leonard Schleicher) is working for the Resistance.  He happens to be a radio operator on board the U-612.  The local Resistance unit is led by Spanish Civil War veteran named Carla Monroe (Lizzy Caplan) who is a chain-smoking, morphine addicted fanatic.  Simone goes to work for her making for some tense moments in her romance with Forster.  There is some thought provocation with Simone and Carla representing different views on whether civilians are expendable for the greater cause.

                        If you’re going to do eight episodes, you can’t spend them all on a sub, apparently.  Plus, its hard to get a lesbian love scene.  The two arc approach works fairly well.  Surprisingly, the land-bound espionage plot is the better one.  With spy stories, we expect to suspend reality to get the close calls characteristic of the genre.  This arc is aided by the charismatic Wlaschiha (from “Game of Thrones”) and Caplan (from “Castle Rock”).  Overall, the cast of the series is fine, with Okon effective as untraditionally cautious Hoffman and Konarske malevolent and unhinged as Wrangel.  The triangle between Simone, Monroe, and Forster is unpredictable with the characters being intriguing.  It helps a lot that the subtitling is way above average, so their dialogue comes through accurately.  
  
                        The effort that went into the production is impressive.  It does not equal the movie, but its not a cheap knock-off.  The interior of the sub gets you right back on Das Boot.  The camera follows the crew through the interior.  The lighting is excellent.  And you also get the aural motif from that movie.  This nicely connects the two boats, although there is no connection in the narrative.  The sub plot is much more complicated than a typical tour.  And here is the main problem.  Where the movie “Das Boot” was a realistic depiction of a u-boat voyage, the series fills its extra running time with some outlandish plot developments.  The clicheish command dysfunction is poorly handled. Hoffman does not get off to the rocky start you would expect.  In fact, he is a good leader from the start.  Tennstedt may be pissed about not getting command, but he really has no justification for fomenting mutiny.  Hoffman does the stereotypical constant drilling, but it is warranted due to the crew being mostly green too.  He has orders to avoid contact, so the crew might grumble, but would hardly be insubordinate about it.  The show jumps the shark with the reintroduction of the Wrangel character.  What happens after is dramatic, but ludicrous given the nature of the u-boat service.

                        I recommend watching “Das Boot”, the series.  Just don’t expect an extended version of the movie.  You might enjoy it if you want a sub show that is not testosterone fueled.  In other words, it does not disregard the female demographic.  It’s entertaining in a binge-worthy way.

GRADE  =  B   

15 comments:

  1. I personally dislike the series; along with the "politically correct issue" (the lesbian relationship) between the main ladies that comes out of nowhere for no reason. There is too much happening on land, away from the sub itself.

    The idea of swapping Wrangel at all (unless he was very well connected) for a civilian, rather than a Spy as would be customary is ridiculous. As for the deposed Hoffman arriving in New York, there is no way on earth he wouldn't be a POW.

    This series did not do the U-boat sailor's reputation any favors. The original Das Boot gave the characters some dignity and respect and humanised them so much that you forget the fact they were fighting for the wrong side (regardless of some of the crew, including the Captain, having anti-Nazi thoughts). Not this time around. The depiction of the U-boat crew is abhorrent. I was only rooting for Tennstedt, and I understand his willingness to be all gung-ho, regardless of his personal actions. But the rest are savage, brutal, uncaring monsters that not even war can excuse. The ~30% screen time that it got was nowhere enough for me. Not to mention that most of the time even it was just drama inside the boat.

    BTW, this has to be the worst managed u-boat in the history of the Kriegsmarine. Petty conflicts, frequent fistfights among the crew members, blame games, the Kaleun letting the XO get away with blatant disloyalty and insubordination, a general atmosphere of disharmony, and absolutely zero team spirit within the crew. If the German armed forces had been like that, the war would have been over in 2 weeks, with the Polish cavalry beating the German Panzer corps.

    The title was misleading in the first place; I'm a bit annoyed that they sold it as Das Boot. A simple PR stunt. It certainly isn't Das Boot. It's trying to appeal to way too large an audience. Lesbian love story, crime drama and action movie with semi-historical representations of technical procedures. It becomes quite ridiculous in series with few leading characters, where those issues seem shoehorned into the plots.

    The crew on that boat? It's not only the worst in the Kriegsmarine, it's the worst in any navy ever!


    Also, the Wrangel storyline? Why would they risk a very valuable u-boat on that mission? It makes absolutely zero sense other than act as a plot device to reach a climax in the crew conflict storyline. Hoffmann had done nothing that would warrant such behavior from his men. he's a bit of a pain in the ass and he insists on following orders to the letter, but that's hardly unique in any armed force. Especially the sonar operator, who can't tell a single ship from a convoy. Trading a VIP for a POW makes no sense. Also, the story implies that Wrangel is so important that the u-boat must avoid all fights in order to bring him home alive. But he's a u-boat commander, so once he's back home, he'd most likely be sent back out with the opposite orders: pick as many fights as possible. That's just ridiculous. That first woman was unlikeable and could not even save her life.

    The first couple of episodes, I had presumed the parts set in La Rochelle were just window dressing to create an on-shore connection with the crew. I thought a newbie commander would be a sort of journey where the commander slowly but surely brings his crew together and becomes the respected veteran over time.

    Instead what do we get, insubordination? questioning of the Captain and orders from the BdU? mutiny?!... on a U-Boat? I looked it up there are no historical examples of this, the closest historical event that could have vaguely influenced the show is the denouncement of Oskar-Heinz Kusch.

    And that's just for the sections on the boat 60% - 80% of the episodes is set entirely in La Rochelle following some SJW resistance plot line that's only vaguely connected to the boat, and has little if any historical precedence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Preach, brother! You have me wondering what I was thinking when i gave it a B. In my defense, I think I may have been clouded by recent views of Russian war series which are pretty bad. I especially agree on the lesbian subplot, but I believe there is now a requirement that every series include a gay relationship. Watch for it in the next "Expendables" movie. Stallone and Schwarzenegger

      Delete
  2. They aired the second season, and personally, I found it a bit better than the first, they toned down the more violent and explicit sexual tones, and tried to make it more real.

    Do you think you continue to review each season, or are you just leaving it with the first season?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jürgen Prochnow was interviewed for a German Magazine and revealed he was actually offered a role for the third season of the new series. He turned it down, saying that it isn't Das Boot, either related to the film, and said it shouldn't have been called "Das Boot". Honestly, it's hard to disagree with him.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You could definitely see that a PC/SJW writer got ahold of this. The whole lesbian resistance plot was focused on way too much, especially when the two women didn't even know each other and suddenly they are lovers......the relationship between simone and the Gestapo guy was far more interesting as it was gearing the audience up for how she would be apart of the resistance and love her lover at the same time. It made the romance between the two women all the more unlikely and the impression is that it was inserted for a modern audience. Add to this that the stories have to be extended over 8 episodes of one hour each. I don't wish to sound racist or homophobic but it is like the writer was like hey how about we make simone a random lesbian. Why because feminism. First season PC bridged: Only lesbians can be virtuous and men can only be weak or evil. Second season bridged: You can repent of your nazism and be saved by a black woman.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's exactly how I felt about the lesbian subplot. It's almost like it is required in modern movies and series. It's PC pandering, especially in period pieces.

      Delete
  5. Yeah, the thing that made the OG Boot what it was was its focus on the submarine and the submarine alone and that’s just… Not what the show is. I understand that you can’t make an 8 episode show about a single submarine, but a lot of the film’s tragedy and impact gets lost in the show. I mean, it’s still obviously based on the movie, but I agree with Mr. Prochnow that it is a very different piece of media with a very different approach to the story and the themes and sadly, it’s just… A lot worse than the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Do you think you will be reviewing the next two seasons of the series? The third is reportedly the last one.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Season 2 was nearly as bad as season 1, a duel between U-Boats? A second Mutiny? Defecting U-Boat Captains? They clearly ripped off The Hunt for Red October.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Warning: SPOILERS.

      Not only did they rip off Red October, but it makes no sense! Why does the captain (I forget his name... so many men with the same beards!) think the US can benefit from studying an outdated sub? The US Gato's were superior in every way!

      And the Nazi's freaking out, "OMG he might give them the code book!". Then CHANGE THE CODE BOOK! The code book only contained daily key settings and these were changed on a regular basis; and immediately if a breach was suspected.

      And the S2 finale was confusing. I still don't understand which part of Hoffmans story was real and which was hallucination, and why does Wrangler let the other dude stab him (I think that's what happened?) with no retaliation? It wasn't even a deep wound? Is he supposed to die now?

      Also, the portrayal of an alcoholic is laughable. Written by woke idiots who think they know it all, for sure.

      Delete
    2. Some people think Klaus’ affair with Cassandra was inspired by the story of Elinor Powell (1921–2005), an African-American nurse in World War II who married a German prisoner of war.

      Look forward to your rant on Season 3.

      Delete
  8. Series 3 sneak peek: The captain comes out to his crew as transgender. This results in him being removed from his post by the Nazi regime and sent to a concentration camp.

    There, he helps the Jews from the last series escape, along with that French thug. It turns out the thug is also transgender and the two of them get involved in a trans-lesbian relationship.

    At this point we see a U-boat for a few seconds, before getting back to the main storyline.

    They then get arrested by the Gestapo, but then the Gestapo officer has a change of heart and decided to help them escape to America.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha no way. Im just watching Das Boot movie for the first time and was searching if its original language is german. Then I found this haha.

      Delete

Please fell free to comment. I would love to hear what you think and will respond.