“Twelve O’Clock High” is a war movie dedicated to American bomber crews and command in England in 1942. It is based on the novel by Sy Bartlett and Beirne Lay, Jr. It was made with the full cooperation of the Air Force which provided several B-17s and combat footage including from the Luftwaffe. The movie was a hit with the critics and won two Academy Awards (Jagger for Best Supporting Actor and Best Sound Recording) and was nominated for two others (Best Picture and Peck for Actor). It takes its name from the slang for enemy fighters being spotted above and straight ahead.
The film opens in 1949
with a Major Stovall (Dean Jagger) in London. He spies a Robin Hood mug in a
store and immediately buys it. It inspires him to visit his old air base at
Archbury. To the tune of “Don’t Sit Under the Apple Tree” (the movie does a
good job of including some vintage songs), he strolls the weed-covered runways and
flashes back to 1942. It is one of the
greatest openings for any war movie.
Bombers are returning from a mission. One has to make a “wheels up”
belly landing (done by acclaimed stunt pilot Paul Mantz for the unprecedented
sum of $4,500). The pilot, Bishop, is later awarded the Medal of Honor for this
act of heroism. The unit is the 918th Bomber Group and it has a reputation as a
“hard luck” outfit having sustained substantial casualties in America’s new
daylight bombing campaign. Its commander, Col. Davenport (Gary Merrill), feels
the unit is being pushed too much. When he hears that they have to go on a
fourth mission in as many days and at a dangerously low altitude, he goes to
headquarters to visit his friend Col. Savage (Gregory Peck) to complain. Savage
reports to Gen. Pritchard (Milliard Mitchell) that Davenport is
“overidentifying” with his men and is about to crack. Pritchard decides to replace Davenport with
Savage. Awkward. Savage decides what the men need is more
discipline. (His character is similar to
Patton.) His approach is the opposite of
Davenport’s so the movie will contrast the two leadership styles. Savage
believes that what the men need is not a shoulder to cry on but pride and grit.
Savage will face a mutiny because of his
approach.
ACTING: A+
ACTION: N/A
ACCURACY: N/A
PLOT: A
REALISM: A
CINEMATOGRAPHY: B
SCORE: none
BEST SCENE: the scene with the crash landing
BEST QUOTE:
Major Stovall: That is
not why I am drunk tonight. I got drunk because I am confused. I was thinking,
which is a thing a man should not do, and all at once I couldn't remember what
any of them looked like. I, I couldn't see their faces, Bishop, Cobb, Wilson,
Zimmy, all of them. All of you. They all looked alike, just one face. And it
was very young. It confused me. I think I shall stay drunk until I'm not
confused anymore.
“Twelve O’Clock High” is the best movie of its
type ever made. Of course, there are not that many movies about leadership and
stress in WWII bomber operations. But you can compare it to the inferior 1948
“Command Decision” starring Clark Gable to gauge its quality. You might also want
to compare it to “Memphis Belle” to see how newer is not necessarily better.
(“Belle” does make a good companion piece to “High” because it gives more of a
crew perspective). TOH is so good at its subject that for years it was shown in
American officers’ courses as a study in leadership. The military calls the ability
of a leader to send young men to their deaths for the greater cause “moral
courage”. Savage is meant to exemplify this command trait. The contrast between
Davenport’s style and Savage’s is instructive and can lead to productive
discussions on how to handle an underperforming unit in a stressful
environment.
The
movie gets the little details right. Eglin Air Force Base in Florida is a good
stand-in for the fictional Archbury and the producers found a weedy old tarmac
in Alabama for the take-offs and landings. The use of B-17s in the filming is a
big plus and is obviously preferable to CGI. In a related note, Technicolor was
available for the movie, but the makers wisely decided to go with a crisp black
and white so they could blend in the combat footage. The first combat scene comes in a mission to
destroy a ball-bearing factory. The integration of archival footage is
flawless. There is realistic radio chatter. There is no intrusive sound track
and the actual sounds of air combat justify the Academy Award for Sound.
The
acting is outstanding across the board, especially Peck and Jagger. The story
of a hard-ass that drives himself to a breakdown seems plausible. The complete
change of attitude of the transfer-requesting pilots is a bit pat, but typical
of a movie plot. The cliché of the desk-bound officer (Stovall) stowing away on
a mission is to be expected and is based on reality.
The
movie is admirably nonpatriotic. This is probably a reflection of the timing of
its production. The war had been over for four years and the soul-searching
could begin. The mental toll of the war on the warriors could be examined.
However, the movie was made too soon after the war to reflect the later
questioning of the daylight bombing strategy. The movie basically accepts the
Air Force line that the daylight, precision bombing of Germany was a
war-winning proposition. Recent scholarship has called this into question. The
Davenports have had the best of the recent arguments.
ACCURACY: The
screenwriters, Bartlett and Beirne, were associated with the 8th Air Force
during the period the movie is set in so they know of what they wrote. This
gives the movie a special authenticity. Most of the main characters (with the
notable exceptions of Stovall and Gately) are based on real people. Davenport
was Col. Charles Overacher who was removed from command of an underachieving
306th Bomber Group. The writers treat Davenport better than his real-life
counterpart deserves, ironically. It appears that Overacher was actually a poor
leader and disciplinarian (the scene where Savage is not saluted or identified
when he visits the base is based on an actual incident). His last straw was
turning back from a mission for no good reason. He was shipped back to the
states after criticizing Gen. Eaker (Pritchard in the film).
Savage is close to Col. Frank Armstrong who did take
on the task of straightening out the 306th. Like his character in the film,
Armstrong had earlier led the first B-17 strike in Europe. A major departure
from the truth is that the real Armstrong did not suffer a nervous breakdown.
The incident was based on another respected commander. After his short ship-up
task was accomplished, Armstrong returned to headquarters. By the way, in the
book, after his breakdown Savage is promoted to command of 2nd Air Force.
Bishop was based on John Morgan who won the Medal of Honor for a landing
similar to that shown in the film. That’s the only similarity, however. For you
history buffs, Cobb resembles Paul Tibbets of “Enola Gay” fame.
CONCLUSION: “Twelve O’Clock High” is the
gold standard for movie about the stress of command. It is well-executed and
based on actual events and people. This makes it not only authentic
historically, but also true to human nature. It pulls no punches with several
main characters perishing and the protagonist suffering a nervous breakdown.
Although not overtly patriotic, it does give Americans a sense of pride in what
our boys went through in the aerial war with Germany. If you ever wondered why
air crews were allowed to go home after 25 missions whereas the infantry were
in it for the duration, this movie clues you in to the role of stress on combat
effectiveness. It also makes it clear that 25 was an unreachable goal for many.
Thanks for this information. I enjoyed the movie but felt that the command dynamics seemed unrealistic. It is good to know that the situation is indeed ahistorical but interesting to see that the story is inspired by actual people.
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't mind seeing a dramatization of actual events, now that everyone involved is too dead to need to be flattered, handled with kid gloves, or villainized. The facts would of course not be as exciting but it sounds like they could still form the core of a great movie.