Friday, November 20, 2026

SOUTH PACIFIC (1958)

 


            Okay. I know what you are thinking – “what the hell is Kevin doing reviewing a musical?” Yuck. Well, in my defense I would not have watched it if I could not argue it is a war movie. The musical / war genre is probably the sparsest hybrid of war movies. The recent “Drummer Boy” is a rare example of telling a war story with songs. It’s certainly more of a war movie than “South Pacific”, but “South Pacific” is set in wartime and has military characters. It can best be described as a military movie and I count those. If you don’t, I have no problem with that.

            “South Pacific” began as a Rogers and Hammerstein Broadway musical. It was not their first to go from stage to screen. “Oklahoma” and “Carousel” were the first. The play was based on James Michener’s collection of short stories entitled Tales of the Southwest Pacific. Joshua Logan had written the play and he directed the movie. Logan had served in the Army in WWII in public relations and intelligence. He was responsible for “jeep shows” that brought entertainers close to the front lines. Logan had directed Broadway shows before the war and after. He directed two war movies – “Mister Roberts” and “Ensign Pulver”. Only Juanita Hall reprised her role from the play, but she was dubbed for the movie. Of the main characters, only Mitzi Gaynor did her own singing. Gaynor replaced Mary Martin after Ezio Pinza died before filming. Rogers did not want to match her with a new leading man. He was replaced by Rossano Brazzi. Doris Day was considered, but Rogers thought she did not have enough range. Elizabeth Taylor failed an audition when she froze in front of Rogers. Mitzi Gaynor was the third choice.

            The movie was shot on the Hawaiian island of Kauai. The US Navy cooperated with landing craft, trucks, jeeps, planes, and uniforms. This helped with the budget. The movie was a big hit and was Rogers and Hammerstein’s biggest hit until “Sound of Music” seven years later. It was very popular in Great Britain where it played in one London theater for four and a half years!  It made more than its cost in just that one theater. The critics were not as enamored as the public. It did get one Oscar for Best Sound and was nominated for Music and Cinematography. The cinematography was controversial due to the use of color filters for the musical numbers. Logan meant them to stand apart from the other scenes, but it ended up being so jarring that Logan wished he had not gone that route. It was nominated for Golden Globes for Best Musical or Comedy and Gaynor was nominated for Best Actress.

            The movie opens on an unidentified island in the Pacific in 1943. Although the island is not in a war zone, apparently it needs a Seabees unit to construct something. They aren’t going to do much, other than sing. The main romance is between Emile (Brazzi), a French planter, and Nellie (Gaynor) who is a nurse. A Marine Lt. Cable (John Kerr) arrives and wants Emile to help him set up a coastwatcher station on a Japanese occupied island. At first, Emile does not want to risk his life and his future with Nell. That will change, of course. Meanwhile, a second romance is brewing between Cable and Lait, an island girl on the idyllic Bali Hai. Lait happens to be the daughter of the local black marketeer Bloody Mary (Hall). Both romances are going to run into typical romance hurdles. Unbelievably, this all leads to a combat scene! Tbose are F6Fs. Hooray for naval cooperation. Not typically, one of the main characters is killed. But don’t worry, the ending is sealed with a kiss.

            If you are into Broadway musicals, “South Pacific” won’t disappoint. And if you want to watch a war musical that actually has shots fired, you’ll probably like it. It does not rise to the level of the best war musical, “Oh! What a Lovely War”, but it is not a mushy mess. Despite the added action, the movie is rated less than the play mostly because the pairing of Pinza/Martin was better vocally than Brazzi/Gaynor. The dubbing is seamless, so you won’t know which are faking it. Unless you read this review first. All sixteen songs are from the play and you get a bonus tune. Oddly, for a romance musical, there are no duets with Brazzi/Gayner. The soundtrack includes three famous songs: “Bali Ha’i”, “I’m Gonna to Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair”, and “Some Enchanted Evening (#28 on AFI’s 100 greatest movie song). Commendably, Rogers and Hammerstein refused to omit the controversial “You’ve Got to Be Carefully Taught” which posits that racism is not genetic. The film did not play in some theaters in the South. We’ve come a long way. Or have we.

            The acting is not as broad as in your average musical. Other than the Seabees prancing around. Unfortunately, Brazzi is a dud. Perhaps because he was upset that he was not worthy of singing for himself. Howard Keel, Charles Boyer, and Fernando Lamas were considered for the role and any of the three would have been better. Gaynor is better as an actress and her voice is fine. Luther, the leader of the Seabees, is played by Ray Walston (famous for “My Favorite Martian”). You will be impressed with his singing. He is not dubbed. Take that, Brazzi.

            As a musical romance, “South Pacific” is one of the greatest. However, since this is a war movie review, I’ll tell my followers that you should watch it as part of your cinema bucket list, but not in your effort to see all the great war movies. As a war movie, it is average. 

GRADE = C



No comments:

Post a Comment

Please fell free to comment. I would love to hear what you think and will respond.