Last year I went to the WWII museum in New Orleans for a
special advanced showing of Hulu’s miniseries “Catch-22”. It was an ambitious attempt to bring the
famous Joseph Heller novel to the small screen.
The 1970 film is highly respected, but the novel is massive and
complicated so a two-hour movie could not really do it justice. The miniseries is more than twice as long as
the Mike Nichols’ movie. This new
version was developed and written by Luke Davies and David Michod. They took on the difficult task of
transforming the nonlinear, farcical novel that Buck Henry had ably adapted for
the movie. George Clooney got involved
as an executive producer and directed two of the episodes. He also took on a minor role. Although a prestige production for Hulu, the
rest of the cast was fairly unknown except for Kyle Chandler and Hugh Laurie in
small roles. The miniseries got good
reviews, but only Emmy nods for Sound Effects and Special Visual Effects. It was filmed in Sardinia and Italy. The film used some authentic B-25s.
Davies
and Michod decided to make the miniseries linear, probably as a sop to Hulu’s
audience. It opens with the main
character Yossarian (Christopher Abbott) in training to be a bombardier. He is having an affair with his commanding
officer Scheisskopf’s (Clooney) wife. He
tells her that he chose the air corps because he figured that by the time his
training was over, the war would be over. So it is established early that Yoyo is a
coward. The rest of the show covers
enough bombing missions to prove he would have to be very brave to handle his
job without being affected by it. Although the movie runs for 270 minutes, it
basically covers two storylines. One is
Yossarian’s attempts to get sent back home and the other is the black market
machinations of Milo Minderbinder (Daniel David Stewart). There are ten missions spread out through the
narrative and one montage. Interspersed
with these are some scenes that develop some of the other characters. Col. Cathcart (Chandler) is a martinet who is
constantly upping the number of missions necessary for ending your tour. It starts at 25, but will go up throughout
the miniseries. Major Major (Lewis
Pullman) is a mousy incompetent who is appointed squadron leader. Maj. – de Coverley (Laurie) is in charge of
renting rooms when new cities are occupied.
The
writers had some options when they took on Heller’s book. Buck Henry decided to do a greatest hits
wrapped around the Yossarian / Minderbinder threads. Snowden’s death was his nonlinear device to
explain Yosarrian’s breakdown. Davies and
Michod could have simply replicated that with their own take on the characters
and added more scenes and characters from the book. They could have amped up the black humor and
silliness of the novel. Instead, they
decided to play it relatively straight and concentrate on Yossarian’s efforts
to get to the mission goal. There is
little added from the book and some scenes were not in the book or movie. This was a poor decision because the movie is
not so well known or recent that Hulu’s viewers would have wanted a different
approach. And then you have the fans
that did not want the novel tampered with.
With 270 minutes, the logical approach would have been to cover more of
the book and allow the actors to give their own takes on the books’ characters.
Surprisingly,
the best thing about the series is the missions. The B-25 interiors are authentic. The CGI flak is intense. The sound effects match. You can see and feel why Yoyo is worried
about his life expectancy. At one point,
a fellow bombardier gets splattered on his windscreen. The problem here is the experiences do not
match Yossarian’s reactions. His is not
a consistent descent into PTSD. He
remains dedicated to his bombing with some exceptions. Bizarrely, after doing his best to avoid
missions, Yoyo changes strategy and does multiple missions to reach 50 (the
montage). He is dedicated on all of them
and gets off each bomber with a smile on his face. (Unlike the Yossarian of the book, he does
not care which pilots he flies with.) By
the way, even though he is freelancing, he is always the lead bombardier. The key mission where Yoyo decides to go
around a second time to bomb a bridge is placed too late to make sense. Even more perplexing, the death of Snowden is
in the last episode! It is not used to
explain why Yossarian is so motivated to get out of combat. Instead, it is treated as a breaking point
that leads to Yossarian adopting a no clothes policy. Here is one example of the series going beyond
the movie/book, but this does not happen enough to become a characteristic of the
show. The writers were too tame in this
respect.
The
critics have been kind to the series, although the Emmys were not impressed. However, if you have seen the movie and/or
read the book (which I have, twice), this miniseries is a severe disappointment. The movie’s characters channeled the book’s
well and the cast was outstanding. This
ensemble is definitely second-rate, but the script gives them no opportunity to
make their characters interesting. It
was a poor decision to cast actors that mostly look alike. And, in spite of the expanded length, the
other air crewmen like Nately, Orr, Arfy, McWatt, etc. are short-changed. Hell, we don’t even get Gen. Dreedle. Clooney’s Scheisskopf is substituted as a
mustache twirling villain. Only
Minderbinder makes an impression and only Daniel David Stewart is in a league
with his cinematic equivalent (Jon Voight).
The series adds two Italian lackeys for Milo and forgoes many of the
unseen characters from the book, like Hungry Joe. Across the board, the characters are boring
in comparison to the book/movie. It is
infuriating for fans to see the Chaplain depicted as a typical chaplain! Nately’s whore likes him! Did the writers even read the book? Christopher Abbott is adequate as Yossarian,
but his performance lacks nuance. Yoyo
is unlikeable and much more of a straight coward than Alan Arkin’s portrayal.
This
series needed to be as black, if not blacker, than the movie/book. There is little humor in the series. In a telling moment, Yossarian’s scrotum
surgery (not in the book) forces him to wear silly pants. It was
too late to shift to farcical.
Why would you add a scene where Yoyo spends some time in an Italian
village and skip some of the iconic scenes? You had 270 minutes! There is no briefing with Dreedle’s WAC being
the focus. Milo does not have a cotton
problem. There is no Luciana. Arfy does not visit Yoyo during a
mission. The key scenes that are
reenacted are all inferior to the movie. For example, Kid Sampson’s death is played for
shock value and makes no reference to Doc being on board McWatt’s plane.
I
do not understand the critics who have complimented the miniseries. To me, it is a big disappointment. The decision to disregard the tone of the
book and not simply expand on what the movie covered is head-scratching. To take beloved characters and remove their
quirks is inexcusable. The changes that
were made to the story dilute the satire. There’s no verve. Next time, use “MASH” as the template.
_Film_Poster.jpeg)
