In honor of the seventieth anniversary of D-Day, I would like to inform my
readers of some options for cinematic takes on the famous invasion. Surprisingly, there are not that many options
for this topic. The movies that use
Operation Overlord either as the subject or the setting vary wildly in quality. There are several great ones and several
embarrassments. Before revealing my list
and rankings, allow me to get specific about one of the better ones.
In
2001, HBO premiered a miniseries based on the bestseller by Stephen
Ambrose. “Band of Brothers” chronicled
the history of Easy Company, 506th Parachute Infantry, 101st
Airborne from training through Normandy to the end of the war in Europe. Episode 2 entitled “Day of Days” dealt with
D-Day. It was directed by Richard
Loncraine (“The Gathering Storm”) and written by John Orloff (who received an
Emmy nomination). The episode follows
Lt. Dick Winters (Damian Lewis) through the night and first day of the
invasion. Winters is in command of a
“stick” of ten paratroopers that cross the English Channel on a C-47. The interior is an actual C-47 and the
close-ups on the men’s faces are just as authentic. You see the variety of emotions and little
idiosyncracies of men about to face the elephant for the first time. Although Winters has never been in combat,
his cool and inspiring demeanor evidence a great leader in the making.
The convoy of C-47s come under hellacious anti-aircraft fire. This is the first time the mini-series gets to show off the production values that made it the most expensive mini-series of all time (until its sister series “The Pacific” came out). The CGI is excellent and the sound effects are awesome. It is a chaotic scene with plenty of fireworks. One thing about the series, it really rewards repeat viewings as the characters tend to get lost in the fog (and darkness in this case) of war. Once you can identify the multitude of Easy members, you can recognize their roles in the invasion. When Winters’ plane takes flak, the pilot panics and green-lights the drop before the drop zone is reached. Winter’s jump is shown in the now iconic POV. Upon landing, he hooks up with a PFC Hall (played by Andrew Scott, later Sherlock Holmes’ Moriarty). When Hall comments that they are lost, Winters counters: “We are not lost, we’re in Normandy”. Given the confusion of the paratrooper landings, that was a pretty bold assumption.
The convoy of C-47s come under hellacious anti-aircraft fire. This is the first time the mini-series gets to show off the production values that made it the most expensive mini-series of all time (until its sister series “The Pacific” came out). The CGI is excellent and the sound effects are awesome. It is a chaotic scene with plenty of fireworks. One thing about the series, it really rewards repeat viewings as the characters tend to get lost in the fog (and darkness in this case) of war. Once you can identify the multitude of Easy members, you can recognize their roles in the invasion. When Winters’ plane takes flak, the pilot panics and green-lights the drop before the drop zone is reached. Winter’s jump is shown in the now iconic POV. Upon landing, he hooks up with a PFC Hall (played by Andrew Scott, later Sherlock Holmes’ Moriarty). When Hall comments that they are lost, Winters counters: “We are not lost, we’re in Normandy”. Given the confusion of the paratrooper landings, that was a pretty bold assumption.
Winters
and Hall encounter other paratroopers, some of whom are from the 82nd
Airborne. They ambush a German supply
wagon in a culvert and we get the first look at the kinetic violence that marks
the miniseries. A theme is established
as “Wild Bill” Guarnere (Frank John Hughes) questions Winters’ leadership
abilities. When Winters’ little group
links up with a larger unit, Malarkey (Scott Grimes playing the Easy Company
member who spent the most time in combat of the entire company) talks with a
fellow Oregonian who was in the German army and is now a POW. Subsequently, the legendary Lt. Speirs
(Matthew Settle) prisoner incident occurs.
Even
though Easy Company is scattered all over the country, there is enough of a core
group to be given a key mission. Winters’
job is to take out a battery of 105s that threaten the Utah Beach egress. He sketches out the plan for his men and the
audience. The reenactment of what is
known as the Brecourt Manor Assault is depicted in the style that the
miniseries is famous for. It builds on
the “Saving Private Ryan” cinematography.
This features lots of hand-held with an emphasis on close-ups. We follow Winters as he leads the
assault. The miniseries proudly eschews
clichés by putting Sgt. Lipton (Donnie Wahlberg) up a tree without the usual
results. The action is frenetic and the
deaths are realistically random.
Soldiers make mistakes and do foolish things. Once again the sound effects are a standout.
By
the end of the day, Winters has earned the respect of his men (in particular,
Guarnere) and has suffered his first lost men.
They won’t be the last and one great thing about the rest of the
miniseries is the suspense of who will survive.
The episode concludes with narration by Winters. He dreams of a quiet, peaceful life after the
war. A post script informs the viewers
that several members of Easy Company were awarded medals for the Brecourt Manor
Assault. Winters was decorated with the
Distinguished Service Cross.
"Hey fellas, someday Coach Hardy's class will study this action" |
If
I may get personal, I have to admit I have a strong affinity for “Band of
Brothers” in general and this episode in particular. I read Ambrose’s book long before the
mini-series was a gleam in Tom Hanks’ eyes.
When the mini-series was publicized I got a subscription to HBO just so
I could watch it. (This was right around
the time HBO was going big on prestige mini-series, so that worked out well for
me.) Back in the good old days when I
was teaching my History of Warfare course, I showed most of the episodes. I used “Day of Days” to teach small unit
tactics by using the Brecourt Manor Assault sequence. By the way, so does West Point.
Obviously,
“Day of Days” is a must see for anyone wanting to honor the memory of
D-Day. Here is my ranking of
movies that cover D-Day in one way or another.
1.
"The Longest Day" (1962)
– This is the granddaddy of the battle
epics. It covers the entire invasion
from both the Allied and German perspectives.
The cast is all-star and the scope is breathtaking. All of the key facts about Operation Overlord
are covered in an educational but entertaining way. The only drawback is the dated special
effects and combat, but the lack of graphic violence does not detract from its
relevance to a modern audience or its entertainment value. As proof of this, it won my 2013 March
Madness Tournament to determine the best WWII combat film. It is the best film ever made about D-Day. Grade = A+
2.
Band of Brothers “Day of Days” - Technically not a movie, but certainly
belongs on this list. Each episode of BoB
was almost like a mini-movie. Although small scale in scope, it does cover actual
paratroopers and one of the critical actions on the first day. Grade =
A+
3.
"Saving Private Ryan" ((1998) -
SPR brought D-Day to modern audiences in a big way. It is a fictional
tale of a squad of Rangers sent to rescue the last survivor of four brothers. The opening scene on Omaha Beach is the
greatest combat scene ever filmed and has spawned the recent hyperrealistic
renderings of combat in films like “Band of Brothers”. The rest of the film has come under criticism
for its Spielbergian plot devices which brought in huge audiences, but
polarized the war movie lovers community.
Despite the schmaltzy moments and head scratching implausibilities (and
a central character who is a moron tactically), the movie is still
outstanding. By the way, although Ryan
is a paratrooper, the movie is not about paratroopers. Grade =
A
4.
“Thirty Six Hours” – This is an
espionage thriller with the intriguing premise that the German kidnap an
American staff officer who has knowledge of the invasion plans. A German doctor sets up an elaborate scheme
to trick him into spilling the beans.
Oh, and there’s a babe and an evil Nazi involved. Obviously not based on historical fact, but
still a lot of fun until it gets silly towards the end. Grade
= B
5. "The Americanization of Emily" (1964)
- This farce is set during the lead up to the
invasion. The aide to an addled admiral
is tabbed with documenting the death of a sailor as the first American to die
on the D-Day beaches so the Navy can score a publicity coup. Problem is the aide (who is the stereotyped
movie scrounger) is a practicing coward and does not want to be near any flying
ordnance. Emily is the British widow of
a war hero who falls for him in spite of his avowed survivalism. It’s meant to be scathing satire, but it is
not very funny, has a repugnant main character, an implausible romance, and
does not have the courage of its convictions.
Grade = C
6.
"D-Day - the Sixth of June" (1956) - This is a love triangle set in England before
the invasion. It does culminate in a Pointe
du Hoc type assault, but that is the little action that occurs and it is not
worth the wait. The rest of the movie is
boring with lots of talking and schmaltzy romancing. Grade = D
7.
"Overlord" (1975) - This is a low budget movie about a British soldier
from boot camp through landing in Normandy.
There is a large quantity of actual footage blended into the story, but
much of it is unrelated to the plot (WWII documentary viewers will be very
distracted). Some critics were kind to
the movie, but in reality it is terrible.
Grade = F
8.
"Pathfinders: In the Company of Strangers" (2011) -
D-Day could use a good movie about the Pathfinders who helped prepare
the way for the airborne invasion – this movie is not that movie. It is absolutely terrible. It looks like it was filmed by a third grader
with ADHD using an old camcorder he found in the attic. The actors are his grown up classmates
playing soldier in the back yard. Grade
= F-
I suggest honoring the men who made D-Day a success by watching one of the better movies. If you watch the "Band of Brothers" episode, please keep in mind that of the main characters, only Donald Malarkey is still alive. The Greatest Generation" is passing on and we will not see the likes of it ever again.
I suggest honoring the men who made D-Day a success by watching one of the better movies. If you watch the "Band of Brothers" episode, please keep in mind that of the main characters, only Donald Malarkey is still alive. The Greatest Generation" is passing on and we will not see the likes of it ever again.
HISTORY
or HOLLYWOOD: “Day of Days” (BoB episode
2)
Which of the following incidents depicted in the episode are historically accurate and which are Hollywood inventions?
Which of the following incidents depicted in the episode are historically accurate and which are Hollywood inventions?
1.
Winters’ C-47 was taking anti-aircraft
fire so the pilot turned on the green light early.
2.
Winters landed without a weapon other
than his knife. He was joined by a
stranger named Hall. They met up with
other paratroopers as they moved. They were
all far from where they were supposed to land.
3.
Winters’ group ambushed a German
supply wagon in a culvert and Guarnere opened fire prematurely because he
wanted revenge for the recent death of his brother at Monte Cassino. The Germans and the horses were dispatched
with extreme force.
4.
Lt. Speirs offers some German
prisoners (one of whom was an American who fellow-Oregonian Malarkey had
previously been talking to) cigarettes and then machine guns them.
5.
Winters is assigned the task of
eliminating a battery of 105 howitzers
that were threatening the causeways leading out of Utah Beach.
6.
Winters uses the German trench system
to take each of the guns and spike them using C-4 and grenades.
7.
“Pop” is wounded in the ass, Compton
drops a grenade, Lipton climbs a tree, Compton hits a fleeing
German in the back with a grenade, Malarkey risks his life for a Luger, and Hall
is killed randomly.
8.
Winters finds a valuable map in a
German dugout that pinpoints German artillery and machine gun positions in the
area.
9.
Speirs leads the assault on the final
gun in a Rambo sort of way.
10.
Winters takes his first drink of liquor that
night.
1.
Winters’ C-47 was taking anti-aircraft fire so
the pilot turned on the green light early.
History To tell the truth, the
episode lays the anti-aircraft fire and the results on a bit thick, but the
effects are so spectacular who cares?
2.
Winters landed without a weapon other
than his knife. He was joined by a
stranger named Hall. They met up with
other paratroopers as they moved. They were
all far from where they were supposed to land.
Histywood Winters did lose his
M-1 on the drop. He, like most
paratroopers, landed far off target. He
met up with other men, but Halls (Hall in the episode) was not one of them.
3.
Winters’ group ambushed a German supply wagon
in a culvert and Guarnere opened fire prematurely because he wanted revenge for
the recent death of his brother at Monte Cassino. The Germans and the horses were dispatched
with extreme force. Histywood It was actually four wagons and some of the
Germans escaped. The Germans were in
open ground, hence the escapes. The
American force was much larger and Guarnere was not near the front so did not
open the engagement. He had lost a brother
recently at Casino. (This incident did
accurately reflect the German reliance on horse-drawn transportation.)
4.
Lt. Speirs offers some German
prisoners (one of whom was an American who fellow-Oregonian Malarkey had
previously been talking to) cigarettes and then machine guns them. Histywood
The incident was believed to be true by members of Easy Company, but
there is no proof that it happened.
Generally speaking, paratroopers were at least encouraged (if not
ordered) to not take prisoners. It would
have been likely that a man like Speirs would not have burdened himself with
any German that raised his hands that day. However, it is highly unlikely that any
officer would have executed prisoners under the circumstances depicted in the
show (men who had already safely surrendered and were in an occupied zone). My opinion is that the “legend” grew out of
the actual shooting by Speirs of some hand raising Germans during action that
night which would have made taking prisoners impractical. The story got ballooned from there (as the
mini-series implies with humor). Contrast
this with Capt. Miller’s ridiculous decision in SPR to set free the German
prisoner at the radar station. As far as
Malarkey’s fellow state-mate, the meeting did happen but not in connection with the
alleged execution. The conversation was almost verbatim, but the German-American was from Portland, not Eugene.
5.
Winters is assigned the task of
eliminating a battery of 105 howitzers that were threatening the causeways
leading out of Utah Beach. History
6.
Winters uses the German trench system
to take each of the guns and spike them using C-4 and grenades. History
Not surprisingly, the actual action took three hours, not fifteen
Hollywood minutes. Other than that, the
depiction is astoundingly accurate.
7.
“Pop” is wounded in the ass, Compton
drops a grenade, Lipton climbs a tree, Compton hits a feeling
German in the back with a grenade, Malarkey risks his life for a Luger, and Hall
is killed randomly. History Virtually every little incident actually happened. One little caveat - Winters did not have a personal connection to
Halls.
8.
Winters finds a valuable map in a
German dugout that pinpoints German artillery and machine gun positions in the
area. History And he did turn the map over to Nixon.
9.
Speirs leads the assault on the final
gun in a Rambo sort of way. History As shown, he left the trench to make the assault. I am a big fan, but Speirs' tactics probably cost the lives of two of his men.
10.
Winters takes his first drink of liquor that
night. History And Winters was not a Quaker (as Guarnere had
posited), but was a strait-laced Mennonite.
RATING = .85
An
85% rating for accuracy is extremely high and indicates that this episode of “Band
of Brothers” is the most accurate rendering of D-Day yet.
the Brecourt Manor Assault
thanks for providing the list, I have not seen several of those movies, since I am waiting until I cover the landings. Liked you, I loved Band of Brothers, but I am not a fan of SPR, for the reasons you mentioned basically. Would the Big Red One also fit on the list? It has that scene on Omaha Beach with the Bangalore mines, although it does not actually spend much time on D-Day.
ReplyDeleteI considered BR1, but as you say, it spends only one scene on D-Day. I do not feel it can be classified as a D-Day movie.
ReplyDeleteI watched some interviews with RAF pilots yesterday. It was quite moving, alos because it was obvious those gusy wouldn't be around for the 80th anymore. We should have travelled to Normandy. The planes were quite impressive. Anyway - There are a few movies on your list I haven't watched so I might have some catching up to do.
ReplyDeleteI'd like to re-watch BoB. It still is one of my favourites.
They are going fast. As I mentioned, only Malarkey (of the main characters) is still alive. In the last two years Compton and Guarnere passed away. Winters died about three years ago as I recall.
ReplyDeleteI've been meaning to rewatch it as I am trying to work my way through the various mini-series. I have already reviewed (but not posted) The Pacific, The Winds of War, and Piece of Cake.
Great write up - I too got caught up in the passion as I watched BoB starting last week and then restarted it again this AM. I also love SPR - it is a good movie and I thinks folks are way too critical of it - movies are made to entertain and depending on the director, will get some varying degree of accuracy. Bat the end of the day, their prime directive is to entertain - not to document. If people want pure accuracy, then documentaries are your pick.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the generation that fought in WW2 are sadly leaving this Earth. They were a great bunch but I do think we can see another like them again but probably not in our lifetime - which is maybe what you meant...
In honor of Easy Company - CURAHEE
LOL - horrible typist - I meant to say...
DeleteI agree that the generation that fought in WW2 that are sadly leaving this Earth were a great bunch - one of the best - but I do think...
Just to make a factual correction to your fact checks:
ReplyDelete#3) You are correct. The director changed the staging of the scene to make it as it appears. It was originally written as you wrote, which is actually not the complete truth either. Only years after the mini-series did Guarnere tell me what really happened that night.
#4) History. It happened, though the man from Eugene Oregon was not there in reality.
In term of Hall/Halls, Winters remembered his name as Hall, hence his name is Hall in the series (we didn't have a way to check it pre-internet). Winters DID know Halls from the 101st Basketball team.
And thanks for acknowledging how accurate the battle scene is. It was very difficult to figure it out. I interviewed everyone that was involved and alive at the time (1999), and they all had slightly different stories. What you saw was what I figured out. I now see my version has become the official one on the internet, though there is some differences of opinion as to how the 4 gus are positioned.
Best
John Orloff, writer DAY OF DAYS
I have to apologize. I had responded to your comments promptly, but somehow it did not get posted. I greatly appreciate your responding to my post and am honored.
Delete80 years later . Emotional
Delete