“Whiskey, Tango, Foxtrot” is a
dramedy about a female journalist in Afghanistan from 2003-2006. It is based on the memoir “The Taliban
Shuffle: Strange Days in Afghanistan and Pakistan” by Kim Barker. The movie
assures us it is “based on a true story”.
It was directed by the team of Glenn Ficarra and John Requa. The movie was a pet project of Tina Fey who
was interested in Barker’s story early on after someone mentioned to her that
she would be ideal for the role. The
movie was made by her production company and produced by mentor Lorne
Michaels.
The movie opens with a cocaine
fueled party in Kabul in 2006. The
partiers are journalists blowing off steam.
They are interrupted by a nearby explosion. At this point the film drops back to 2003 to
start our heroines arc. Kay (Fey) is a
network news peon who decides to volunteer for reporting from Afghanistan
because she qualifies as “unmarried and childless”. All she has is a steady boyfriend who is
supportive of her career move. They can
make it work. Sure, why not? Before you can say cancel the wedding plans,
she is corkscrew landing at Kabul International Airport (KIA – get it?) to
avoid missiles. She is assigned an
interpreter/fixer named Fahim (Christopher Abbott). No Afghan actors available in Santa Fe?
Kay is introduced to the
denizens of the frat house the journalists live in. This boys club includes one other female
named Tanya (Margot Robbie) who does not want the audience to go to the trouble
of discovering that she is a male war correspondent sexually, so she comes
right out and asks Kim if she can sleep with her security detail. She suggests Kay take advantage of the fact
that women who are marginally sexy in the States are 10s in Afghanistan. This movie might have a great effect on
American women booking trips to Kabul.
(Especially those that consider Tina Fey to be a dog.)
Kay’s first embed is at a forward
operational base. She does the requisite
“where you from soldier?” interviews and becomes friends with a Marine who
insists he does not believe in chambering his weapon. This bizarre inclusion in the montage will
come back as a major plot point. She also
strikes up a relationship with a General Hollander (Billy Bob Thornton) who
admonishes her to not take advantage of her sudden rise on the female rating
scale to have sex with his Marines. By
this time in the war, a typical mission is to investigate the blowing up of a
well in a village. On the way back,
their convoy is ambushed and Kay uses the sudden rush of adrenalin to get film
of a Javelin missile taking out a Toyota Taliban tank. This act of balls earns her the generals
respect and the explosion earns her air time.
The second embed also involves a
sabotaged well, but this time it’s not the Taliban to blame. It’s a Tina Fey movie so we need to have some
social commentary of the female rights variety.
This is followed by a trip to a school destroyed because of its female
students. As time goes on she goes from
“what the hell have I gotten myself into?” to “when do I get my next fix of whizzing
shrapnel?” She has also evolved amorally
and strikes up a relationship with the previously “not in a million years” rake
Iain (Martin Freeman). Their
relationship has as bright a future as Afghanistan. And her relationship with girlfriend Tanya is
equally solid. A BFF (bitch friend
fortheduration) wouldn’t be as competitive as a male colleague, would she? Nor would your male lover, right?
Some will make their decision to
watch this movie based on their feelings toward Tina Fey. In my case, I love her, so it was a
no-brainer. If you consider her to be a
raging liberal feminist, chill out because she is not using the movie as a
forum for her loathsome views. The movie
is surprisingly light on political commentary. It does not question our
involvement in Afghanistan. It does not even question why we are still
there. Instead, there is a theme of
America losing interest in the war. If
anything the movie is pro-military. All
of the Marines are positive characters, including one who gives his legs for
his country. In another surprise,
General Hollanek is super cool. His
periodic appearances really juice up the movie.
Although their relationship starts predictably rocky, he turns out to a
leader who is willing to adjust his views when confronted by new information
provided by Kim. He also gets some
kickass lines. When Kim asks him how the
war is going, he describes it as like “fucking a gorilla, you keep going until
the gorilla wants to stop.” The movie is
also pro-journalism, but it does portray war correspondents as stereotypically
hard partiers (like WWI fighter pilots).
It updates the cliché of journalists being ruthlessly competitive for
scoops to include female war correspondents.
Throw in a bit of the anything for a scoop mentality.
“Whiskey, Tango, Foxtrot” aims
at the easy target of network news, but it does not hit the target with an RPG.
It is more subtle than that. The two biggest gets by Kim and Tanya both
involve explosions caught on film - with the definite implication that no
explosion, no air time. However, when
Kay confronts her boss about lack of coverage of Afghanistan, her boss
logically explains that if the public is not interested… The movie does not so much criticize as state
facts. Hopefully the movie will remind
the public that we still have troops in the god-forsaken country. And the gorilla still insists on being fucked.
The movie is well made. The
Santa Fe sets look like a Middle Eastern country. There are some attempts at local color. Fahim gets a Muslim wedding. Kay dresses in a burkha (“the blue
prison") to infiltrate a medieval “discussion” of modern technology. The movie also makes token efforts to give us
a taste of Afghan culture. There is a
running joke that if you put a turban on Kay, she would be a mighty fine boy -
worthy of intercourse with an Afghan leader.
Speaking of jokes, the movie is more drama than comedy, but there are
many humorous lines. The movie eschews
slapstick. Although it’s closest
equivalent in war movies is “MASH”, it is not as broad or subversive. It is also not as episodic. “WTF” has more of a traditional storyline and
this is a weakness because some of the plot is cliché and predictable. Since it’s been a while since we had a
significant addition to the war journalism subgenre (and none on Afghanistan),
the clichés are not that stale. Another
similar weakness is the predictability.
All four of the principal relationships end as you would expect. This makes the movie more comfortable than
daring. But maybe this was because they
were so true to the book. Just kidding.
A strength of the film is the
cast. Whatever your visceral reaction to
Fey, she is quite good in a mainly dramatic role. That does not mean she does not showcase her
famous snarky brand of humor. Robbie is
good as her slutty gal pal and gives one a chance to ponder if the Fox News
bunnies were similarly bedded when they embedded. Freeman is fun as the wolfish MacKelpie. Thornton comes off best as General Hollanek. The character could have easily been a
caricature. It says a lot for Fey that
she would let him steal their scenes and allow him to get some of the best
lines. His character also balances the
strong female characters.
“Whiskey, Tango, Foxtrot” (good,
if inaccurate, change of title) is a worthy addition to the war journalism subgenre. It does have two brief combat scenes to help
it qualify as a war movie. The Marine
raid to rescue a hostage is especially well done and different enough from the
night vision/POV style currently in vogue.
As Kay points out to Hollanek, America needs a reminder that it’s not
just the Special Forces that conduct raids.
I won’t complain that the whole hostage scenario was probably invented
to get some more action into the film.
GRADE = B
Thanks for your review. I was debating whether to see this movie or not. And while I do not agree with Tiny Fey's politics, I do like her in 30 Rock.
ReplyDeleteP.S. I think she is cute.
She is probably too cute to play a woman who is rated a 4 according to the movie.
DeleteAlso in the Afghanistan vein, may I suggest you try "Hyena Road" (2015).
ReplyDeleteThanks for the recommendation. I just watched it. Entertaining, but not special.
DeleteI really liked this film a lot. Great review Kevin although you did leave out the loathsome Afghani "morals minister", which really did make for good commentary I thought....
ReplyDeleteI try to keep the reviews from going too long. That's probably why I left him out.
Delete