Wednesday, December 25, 2013

THE TWELVE DAYS OF CHRISTMAS

        Since I have the Holidays off, I have decided to see if I can watch and review 12 movies and post them over the next twelve days.  Probably too ambitious, but what the heck.  Anyway, here goes.


THE TWELVE DAYS OF CHRISTMAS:  On the first day of Christmas, my true love gave to me:  one God in a cockpit…
 
 

                “God is My Co-Pilot” is a flag-waving WWII movie released in 1945.  It is based on the smash hit autobiography of Robert Lee Scott, Jr.  Scott served as a technical advisor and did some stunt flying for the film.  It is true to his story and certainly retains the spiritual theme.  The film had the full cooperation of the Air Force which provided several P-40s and B-25s and AT-6s to masquerade as Zeros.

                A montage takes Scott (Dennis Morgan) from jumping off a roof with an umbrella to a secret mission to India as a bomber pilot.  Along the way he gets his first sermon from the family black guy about the need for God instead of luck in the cockpit.  Scott remains skeptical for most of the film.  The interlude in India gets the requisite exotic locale in and clues us in on two facts.  One, there are belly dancers in India.  Two, WWII air crewmen said things like “jiminy crickets” and “jumping jehosafats”.  God would approve.  

                After a stint flying the Hump into China, Scott hooks up with Gen. Chennault (Raymond Massey) and Father “Big Mike” (Alan Hale).  He is assigned a fighter and helps defend the base against an attack led by the legendary “Tokyo Joe” (Richard Loo).  This is one of the most hilarious scenes in war movie history as the opposing pilots trash talk through the dog fight.  Naturally the Japanese speak American.  Here is a sampling:

                Tokyo Joe:  “Okay, you Yankee Doodle Dandies, come and get it.  I’m going to drop one right in Chennault’s lap.  Where are you gangsters?  Come on up and get a load of that scrap metal you sold us.”

                Johnny:  “Now repeat after me.  Your mother was a turtle, your father was a snake and you’re a good Jap.”

                        Crew chief:  “Why you dirty retail monkey!”

                        Johnny:  “One meatball in the side pocket.”

                Scott turns into the star of the unit and his home town follows him like Joe Dimaggio.  He duels with Tokyo Joe, but they both run out of ammo before they run out of zingers.  He flies Father Mike through a storm which inspires the priest to give a sermon about what a wonderful co-pilot God would be.  The sun emerges as though to smack Scott upside the head.  In the climactic duel, Tokyo Joe is outnumbered two to one and even the samurai sword he carries on board does not make up for Scott’s co-pilot.

               

                “God is My Co-Pilot” is unique in balancing its flag-waving propaganda with cloying religiousity.  That is not a winning combination, although the movie was a hit with those patriotic Bible-thumping rubes that made up 1940s audiences.  Sorry, greatest generation grandparents, I couldn’t help that one.  Even if you take out the sermons and the lame taunting, the dialogue is atrocious.  The music matches it.  The action is fair.  The dog fights are not “Wings” worthy, but they are swirling.  We get a lot of cockpit views and bullet holes in the glass indicating death.  Planes tend to blow up and no one parachutes.  The movie has a large amount of droning.  The acting is average.  Earnest, but not scene-chewing. 

 

                Was it a good Christmas present?  If God is asking – yes!  Otherwise, I would have preferred a lump of coal.

 

grade =  D

Tuesday, December 24, 2013

We Were Soldiers (2002)


                “We Were Soldiers” was based on the acclaimed best seller We Were Soldiers Once…And Young by Lt. Col. Harold Moore and journalist Joseph Galloway.  The book is a non-fiction account of the Battle of Ia Drang in the Vietnam War.  The movie was written, directed, and produced by Randall Wallace of “Braveheart” and “Pearl Harbor” infamy. 

                The film opens with a scene set in 1954 during the First Indochina War pre-Dien Bien Phu.  A French unit is ambushed in the Ia Drang Valley (the Valley of Death) by the Vietminh led by Nguyen Huu An  and wiped out.  The action is graphic with “Saving Private Ryan” style cinematography (quick cuts, slo-mo, POV).  It’s a great opening and sets the theme of “how will the American experience be different?”

                The body of the film begins at Fort Benning, Ga (it was filmed on location) in 1964.  Back when America was innocent, naïve, and overconfident.  And clueless about nonconventional warfare in a jungle environment.  Moore (Mel Gibson) arrives with his idyllic family of supportive wife and perfect kids.  A 1950s TV family in a 2000s war movie that wants to be a John Wayne movie.

Plumley and Moore - comedy team
                Moore is in command of a new type of unit – air cavalry.  Helicopters will take the role of horses.  The unit is the 7th Cavalry and in case you don’t get the reference, the movie hammers the fact that the 7th was Custer’s unit and you know what happened to them!  We get the obligatory training montage.    The movie is an excellent study in command.  Moore is the classic “lead by example” commander.  He is also very hands-on in his leadership.  This includes counseling his young officers.  For instance, he has a talk with a new father named Lt. Geoghegan (Chris Klein) in a chapel.  The scene is cringe-inducing with overt religiousity and sappy dialogue.  Geoghegan is saintly and soon to be a papa with his new bride (and thus doomed).  Moore offers a prayer that concludes with asking God to disregard the enemy’s prayers and help us kill the “little bastards”.  Hilarious!

Geoghegan and Moore pray to prey
on our enemies
                The movie makes a concerted effort to integrate the families into the narrative.  Moore tells his daughter that war is when some people in another country try to take the lives of people and then soldiers like daddy have to go over and try to stop them.  This is not a bad analysis of what the public was told the war was about in 1964.  The movie introduces us to the officers’ wives.  Julie Moore (Madeline Stowe) is the sorority mom.  When orders come, the men are enthusiastic about going off to test their manhood, the wives are stoically nervous.

                The unit is sent to the Central Highlands in 1965.  The air cavalry experiment is about to begin.  That experiment is simple – use mobility to “find the enemy and kill them”.  Their first mission is to land in an enemy area and provoke combat.  Hopefully not against ten to one odds.  Oops!  Hueys led by Maj. Crandall (Greg Kinnear) drop them in a clearing designated LZ X-Ray.  The tactics are realistic as the Americans come charging off the choppers guns blazing and immediately establish a perimeter.  Things go wrong immediately as the gung-ho Lt. Herrick (Marc Blucas) goes chasing after an enemy scout and gets himself killed (“If I have to die. I’m glad to give my life for my country.”) and his platoon cut off in a position called The Knoll.  Sgt. Savage (Ryan Hurst) takes command.  The trials the Lost Platoon will go through are incredible.  A few men holding out against huge numbers of the enemy.  The fighting gets so desperate Savage calls artillery fire down on his own position.


                Inside the perimeter, it’s a macrocosm of what the Lost Platoon is going through.  The landing at LZ X-Ray was like kicking an ant pile.  It turns out there is a NVA battalion commanded by now Col. An stationed in the hills nearby and they are up for a fight.  Even against the vaunted U.S. Army.  The battle is a series of enemy assaults and Moore’s attempts to plug the holes with his courageous few.  Crandall’s helicopters participate by bringing in reinforcements and supplies and medevac the wounded under fire.  They also bring in an intrepid photojournalist named Joseph Galloway (Barry Pepper).  At one point, the NVA get to the command post and Galloway grabs an M-16 and fights for survival, like everyone else.

                At this point the movie jumps to the home front where the wives are coping with separation, but not death.  Then the first telegrams arrive.  Julie Moore and Barbara Geoghegan (Keri Russell) take over delivering the death notices.  It’s extremely poignant and effective.  Wouldn’t it be extra poignant if one of the telegrams is for one of them?

Mrs. Geoghegan and Mrs. Stowe
delivering telegrams
                Meanwhile, day two dawns to more of the same.  Now the VC have joined in, for Christ’s sake!  Geoghegan and a black soldier make a two man assault so racism can be eliminated and Geoghegan can leave his body in no man’s land to be found by Moore later.  Hail, Hollywood!  The enemy break-through in several places and it begins to look like those Custer premonitions will come to fruition.  It gets so bad Moore has to call for “Broken Arrow” (when all available aircraft drop ordinance on a unit about to be overrun).  Some friendly fire napalm roasts Pfc. Nakayama because he had made the mistake of bragging about his new born.  Two proud fathers, two doomed soldiers.  The movie implies the Broken Arrow incident turns the tide.  Soon after, another attempt to reach the Lost Platoon is successful.  Savage takes a short breather and then reenters combat because if you have a name like that …


Napalm + Hollywood = box office dynamite
                On the third day, An plans an all-out assault to finish off the exhausted Americans and thus convince the Yankees that South Vietnam is a bad investment.  This will be the ultimate vindication for his “grab them by the belt buckle” solution to American artillery and air support.  Col. Joshua Chamberlain, I mean Lt. Col. Moore, looks at the situation and decides it calls for a bayonet charge.  “Fix bayonets!”  Moore (Gibson)  leads the charge.  The enemy are too surprised to fire their weapons.  However, the thrill of the chase carries our heroes smack into the well- defended enemy bunker complex.  Get more telegrams ready, including one for Julie Moore.  But wait, the air cavalry arrives in the form of Crandall in a Huey gunship and he proceeds to Gatling and rocket the enemy to smithereens.  USA! USA! USA!

                An licks his wounds and prepares for the long haul.  The media arrives like vultures to report the great “victory”.  Moore is the last to leave, as he promised.  The rest is history.  Spoiler alert:  we lost.

                This is a schizophrenic movie.  Parts of it are great and parts are not.  Not surprising for a movie that tries to be accurate and entertaining in equal measure.  Wallace insisted the movie was as accurate as possible (the same bull shit he spewed about “Braveheart”) and most of it is.  The parts that are aimed at the general audience make a war movie lover squirm.  The Moore family scenes are not pathetic, but it’s obvious Wallace meant to make the opposite of the unpatriotic, impious Vietnam flicks like “Platoon”, “Apocalypse Now”, “Full Metal Jacket”, and “The Deer Hunter”.  The pre-battle training sequence is simplistic and heavy in foreshadowing.  For instance, Herrick is a tightly-wound glory hound who is likely to get his men into a trap.   Sure ‘nuff.   The references to Custer’s Last Stand are too maladroit.  

                The trite pre-Vietnam scenes come to an abrupt end when the unit gets shipped overseas.  That scene is powerful with a building score and no dialogue.  In no time at all, they are in battle.  The action is consistently intense and some of the effects are spectacular.  This movie has more combat than a vast majority of war movies.  And yet, believe it or not, the actual battle was even more intense and violent than the movie.  The tactics are realistic for both sides.  The movie is excellent on helicopter participation in the fighting and air and artillery support.  The napalm shots are breathtaking (get it?).  There is even a “mad minute” moment to get the enemy to reveal their positions.  One problem I had was the lack of emphasis on the role of M-60s in holding off human wave attacks.  It could be argued that “We Were Soldiers” comes closest to accurately portraying a Vietnam battle.

                The movie is rolling along nicely until it jumps the shark with Moore going out in the dark to find Geoghegan.  It is inconceivable that a commander would risk his life in a situation like that.  The scene was obviously forced in to confirm Moore’s pledge not to leave any men behind.  More tears get jerked with the telegram for Barbara.  But Wallace saves his best for last with the abysmal bayonet charge topped off with the Crandall massacre of the remainder of the enemy.  Wallace forces a happy ending into what was a pretty level-headed narrative.  This reminded me a lot of “Pearl Harbor”.  Worse, the success of American grit and firepower in winning the battle dilutes the explicit moral that America will have a hard time in Vietnam.


                The last ten minutes of the movie prevent it from being a very good movie, but it still ends up being good and better than most Vietnam War movies.  The acting is good if a bit too earnest and the cast is able.  The actors were put through a boot camp.  Mel Gibson is not aggravating and gets Moore’s personality right.  It’s obvious Gibson was comfortable playing a man as religious as he is.  Greg Kinnear is strong as Crandall and Pepper’s late appearance as Galloway gives the movie a second wind.  Making the most impact is Sam Elliot as Sgt. Major Plumley.  It’s acting in his sleep, but the character is a lot of fun, if clicheish.  He gets some great lines and provides some welcome humor without cracking a smile.  He does not say a lot, but it’s all quality.  Unfortunately, much of the dialogue could easily fit into a 1940s war film.  When Moore asks Galloway what he is doing there, Galloway says “because I knew these dead boys would be here.”  At one point,  Moore says “There’s nothing wrong except that there’s nothing wrong.”  Apparently, the dialogue is accurate, but it seems hokey.

                The movie is technically proficient as would be expected for a movie costing $70 million.  Wallace may be shaky as a screenwriter, but he does a good job directing.  The action scenes incorporate all the bells and whistles of modern war movies.  There are some hand-held shots.  There is some slo-mo.  Blood splatters on the camera lens.  It is a very violent movie.  The make-up crew did a remarkable job on some horrendous wounds.   Someone counted the number of KIAs – 305.  The sound effects are great.  The lighting in the night attacks is admirable.  The score is fine and restrained.

                The movie has some admirable goals.  Wallace wants the audience to get a feel for what military wives go through.  Having a military mother and having lived on a base while my father flew in Vietnam I can attest to the authenticity of the home front scenes.  The telegram scenes are not in the book and may be Hollywood, but they are refreshing for this macho genre.  We certainly did not need another stale romance or love triangle.  Stowe is great as Julie Moore.  WWS has a strong female vibe.  Another example of balance is the coverage of the enemy.  This is not “Black Hawk Down”.  The communists are not faceless.  Gen. An (Don Duong) is sympathetically rendered as are his men.   One soldier gets to keep a diary with his girl’s picture in it and then gets to try to bayonet Col. Moore.  They are brave but there is definitely a drone quality to them.  Wallace goes out of his way to cover their tactics and even implies they will win the war.

                Some people sneer at the unambiguous religiousity of the film and Gibson’s involvement in the film caters to this criticism.  However, my research shows that Moore is indeed a devout Catholic so the characterization is true to form although obviously forced into the film (probably at the insistence of Gibson).  Considering how a vast majority of war movies purposely ignore religion, we can excuse WWS for purposefully including God.  It has more scenes with religion than any ten war movies.  Hell, even An says a prayer.  Another jarring element is the squeaky cleanness of the American soldiers.  This ain’t “Platoon”.  There is no drug use or sociopathic behavior.  Although I would put the movie in the VioLingo school, I do not think the f word was used a single time.  (Considering the graphic violence, Wallace’s decision to sanitize the language is bizarre.)  Before you cry bogus, this is fairly close to the 1965 Army especially when you consider these would not be draftees and they are in an elite unit.  They should be naïve, enthusiastic, and patriotic.

                In conclusion, “We Were Soldiers” could have been the best Vietnam War movie if Wallace had not pulled his punches in the end.  For someone who wanted to make the most accurate Vietnam War battle movie, it is infuriating that he would taint his admirable effort with a phony happy ending.  Especially when the truth would have fit his purpose so much better.  Still, if you overlook the bayonet charge, the battle is as good as you are going to get, the wives get their just due, the soldiers of both sides are positively depicted, the enemy is sympathetically portrayed, and the movie is an excellent study in command.  Nothing’s perfect.

grade =  A-
trailer
broken arrow

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

DUELING MOVIES: What Price Glory? 1926 vs. 1952



VS.
 
 
 

                “What Price Glory?” was based on a play by Maxwell Anderson and Laurence Stallings.  It is mainly set in the Western Front of WWI.  Both movies are credited with creating the buddy film.  They also created one of the enduring war movie clichés - the battling rivals in love and war.  This is appropriately known as the Quirt/Flagg trope. 
                The Raoul Walsh silent version begins in China where Flagg (Victor McLaglan) is sweet on a prostitute named Mabel.  He gets into a knock down fight with his big rival Quirt (Edmund Lowe).  The film then jumps to the Philippines where Quirt steals Flagg’s Filipino girl friend.  This is supposed to be hilarious and maybe it was in the Twenties.
                Now that we know that Quirt and Flagg are frenemies who are always after the same girl we are off to the Western Front in 1917.  Flagg is now a Captain in command of a company stationed in a French village.  Flagg is billeted at the local tavern where he begins to woo the saucy owner’s daughter Charmaine (Delores Del Rio).  Because this is technically a war movie, the company gets sent to the front for some action.  They attack across no man’s land in a pretty good set piece with plenty of explosions.  To make sure the audience does not enjoy the war Flagg says:  “There’s something rotten about a world that’s got to be wet down every thirty years with the blood of boys like those.”
                Okay, with that out of the way, it’s back to the village for more wooing.  Guess who shows up to complicate the romance?  Flagg goes off on a ten day pass to wine and wench thus leaving Quirt to move in on Charmaine.  She is receptive because he’s a U.S. Marine and they are pretty interchangeable.  When Flagg returns he is confronted by Charmaine’s father who demands that the Marine who “wrecked” his daughter get hitched to her and throw in 500 francs.  He is referring to Quirt and Flagg is guffawing as the mayor is called in to officiate the wedding.  Close call as Charmaine doesn’t cotton to being sold.  Bugles!  Time for another combat interlude.
Quirt, Charmaine, and Flagg
                This time it’s a night attack.  Explosions go off like a pack of firecrackers as our heroes cross no man’s land.  The action is fast-paced and dynamic.  There are deaths, including the “momma’s boy” who dies in Flagg’s arms.  Lt. Kiper rants about the futility of war and asks “what price glory now?” 
                I won’t ruin the ending for you.  I know you will want to watch the movie to find out who gets Charmaine, but since I mentioned that this was the first buddy film you can bet Quirt and Flagg go marching off hand in hand.
#$%^&*! (subtitled:  You are a big poop head!)
                This is a typical silent film in that the acting is hammy and the soundtrack is incessant.  McLaglan is actually pretty good and Del Rio is spicy (thank goodness we did not have to hear her Mexican accent).  The rest of the cast grossly overacts.  They have one character who must have thought he was the Jim Carrey of his day.  His big schtick is doing raspberries.  His constant mugging is supposed to be hilarious, but comes off as desperately creepy.  The humor is basically slap stick with what passed for witty lines.  Like: “why don’t you blow your brains out?”  One reason why the movie is famous is because McLaglan and Lowe were actually swearing at each other which resulted in complaints from lipreaders.  How quaint!  Someone needs to put out an updated version with accurate subtitles.  Apparently noone had problems with the number of ass shots thrown in.  We see each significant female’s derriere before we get to know their face.
                The movie is more of a romance than a war movie.  The two combat scenes are adequate, but are thrown in to break the monotony of the romance.  The company spends no time in the trenches.  They go off twice to cross no man’s land and then it’s home to the village for wining and wenching.  War is Hell – is what the movie is trying to say, ineffectively.   The romance is lame and I did not care who got the girl.  The two main characters are not to root for.  As far as competition with “The Big Parade”, get serious!
                The 1952 version was directed by John Ford and stars Jimmy Cagney (Flagg) and Dan Dailey (Quirt).  The plot is essentially the same, but there is a lot more physical humor and some songs.  The movie actually has a credit for “dances staged by”.  As a war movie lover, I can tell you that you never want to see that at the beginning of a war movie!  Nor do you want to endure songs being sung by characters.  The combat is periphery again and unrealistic.  Ford does not seem to have his heart in the action scenes.  He does have Quirt and Flagg going into no man’s land together (helmetless) and arguing in conveniently placed shell craters.  The movie has a weird vibe by mixing humor and drama less than deftly.
Charmaine and Quirt
                Cagney and Dailey must have been told they were making a silent movie because they do some serious scene-chewing.  Cagney is basically playing Cagney.  It is an embarrassing performance.  There is no chemistry between the leads.  Corinne Calvet is lovely as Charmaine, but cannot act.  We also get a very young Robert Wagner as Pvt. Lewisohn.
                The 1926 version is not a good war movie.  It is overrated as entertainment, but deserves credit for introducing the Quirt/Flagg trope that will reappear in many future movies – not just war movies, by the way.  The remake is inferior although the fact that it is in sound probably makes it more watchable for most viewers.  I would not recommend either. 
Cagney as Flagg

grades:  1926 =  C-   1952 =  D

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

CRACKER? The Wind That Shakes the Barley (2006)


 
                “The Wind That Shakes the Barley” is a war movie set In Ireland in 1920 during the Irish War of Independence.  It was a multinational production directed by Ken Loach.  It was filmed on location in Ireland.  The movie was a big hit with critics and won the Palme D’Or at Cannes in 2006.  It did very well at the box office in Ireland.
                The movie opens with some lads playing a game that I had to read is called “hurling”.  No wonder things are so tense.  The guys get rounded up by thuggish paramilitary types because they have violated the law against public gatherings.  One of the hurlers is defiant and gets beaten to death.  One theme of the movie is that the British are dicks.
                The movie is the tale of the O’Donovan brothers.  Damian (Cillian Murphy) has a bright future ahead as a doctor.  He is pragmatic and not interested in fighting for independence because he feels it is unattainable.   This is in contrast to his older brother Teddy (Padraic Delany) who is the leader of the local IRA brigade.  Teddy tries to convince Damian to join the cause, but is unsuccessful until Damian witnesses the abuse of some railroad workers by some Black and Tans. 
                The violence is back and forth.  The IRA members gun down some British in a pub.  This is followed by one of the rebels named Chris being coerced into ratting out his mates.  The result is Teddy, Damian, and others are captured in the woods.  Teddy is tortured by having his fingernails pulled out.  This is not done graphically and is brief.  Movie over, right?  Nope.  A sympathetic British soldier allows most of them to escape!  “I don’t want your deaths on my conscience.”  That’s going to be a hard sell with his comrades, but there are no consequences and no manhunt to recover the prisoners.  Unrealistic.
                Damian is in temporary command (nepotism much?) as Teddy recovers.  It falls to Damian to execute the traitorous Chris who happens to be a good friend.  Leadership sucks!  The naïve, pragmatic doctor wannabe is getting into this rebellion thing.  He joins the brigade in an ambush of a British convoy on a rural road.  The twenty or so British are killed (no one is wounded – that’s excellent shooting!).  The British decide to evacuate Ireland.  Just kidding.  Can you say retaliation?  This comes in the form of burning farms including that belonging to his girlfriend Sinead’s family.  Damian has to impotently watch her get her hair cut off while hiding in the woods.  Powerful scene, but it ends abruptly.
                Before the next tit-for-tat, word arrives that the war is officially over.  A treaty has been negotiated with the British government giving the southern part of Ireland dominion status.  There is a great scene in a movie theater where the audience reaction indicates the polarizing nature of the compromise.  This polarization is also reflected within the brigade.  The debate is fascinating.  It’s between the old schoolers like Teddy who are willing to accept the potential of peace and the new schoolers like Damian who want nothing less than the whole enchilada.  Have you noticed that Teddy and Damian have switched attitudes?  Neat, huh.
                Teddy joins the new Irish Army because irony is a staple of movies like this.  Speaking of which, ironically Teddy and his new mates use some tactics suspiciously like those British dicks.  Meanwhile, Damian’s crew carries on in the old style and he gets himself captured in a raid to steal weapons.  Will Teddy be able to convince him to see the light and come over to the dark side?
                The film is not based on a true story, but it has some fragments of history in it.  The basic picture is accurate.  The Irish War of Independence was a series of violent confrontations between the Irish Republican Army and British soldiers (either the “Black and Tans” or the auxiliaries) who supplemented the Royal Irish Constabulary.  These soldiers were infamous for atrocities against civilians and destruction of property.   A lot of this was provoked by IRA attacks that targeted the RIC and British supporters like the Black and Tans and the auxiliaries.  This included ambushing and attacks on police stations and barracks.  The movie accurately depicts the nature of the war.
                The ambush in the movie is clearly modeled after the famous Ambush at Kilmichael in County Cork .  17 Auxiliaries were killed by the IRA in a manner similar to the film.  This event occurred one week after Bloody Sunday (when the RIC fired into a crowd at a football match in retaliation for the assassinating of fourteen British operatives earlier in the day).  After the ambush, the British retaliated by burning homes.  County Cork was put under martial law and became a hot bed of the rebellion.
                Although none of the characters are real people, Damian was inspired by Ernie O’Malley.  O’Malley was a legendary figure in the IRA.  He specialized in attacking barracks to acquire weapons.  At one point he was captured, but was allowed to escape by a sympathetic British soldier.  This took place in Kilmainham Gaol.  The jail was the sight of some executions of IRA prisoners.  The movie used the site for some scenes.  He carried on the fight after the treaty and was eventually wounded and captured in a shootout with Free State police.  He escaped execution because of his medical condition.  He spent several years in prison.
                “The Wind That Shakes the Barley” is a thought provoking movie.  I did not know much about the Irish War of Independence before this film.  It is certainly more historical than “The Informer”.  Even though it is not a true story, it is very informative about the dynamics of Ireland during that rough period.  This being a movie, it can be criticized for demonizing the British.  It seems like every group of British soldiers has a sadist in it.  Most of the British are cartoonish.  Loach did come under some heat for his supposedly anti-British vibe.  Hello, he was aiming at an Irish audience.  The movie was very popular in Ireland – mission accomplished.
                The movie is well-acted.  Murphy does a fine job as Damian and the rest of the cast is good.  The movie could have used subtitles for those thick Irish accents.  The cinematography is top notch by Barry Ackroyd.  The scenery is lushly green.  The dialogue is a strength.  The debates clearly delineate the opposing sides within the IRA with regard to the treaty.  The movie may not be fair to the British, but it is balanced in its coverage of the pro-treaty and anti-treaty factions. 
                The movie is a bit heavy-handed in its themes.  Besides that the British suck, Loach also trots out the old “end justifies the means” trope.  We also get a strong dose of war corrupts and war is hell.  The film is a bit predictable and has some clichés.  Damian is the reluctant warrior who grows into rebelliousness.  The brothers end up on opposing sides.  The younger is more impulsive, the older is more practical.  At least that’s how they end up.  They start out the opposite.  There is a brief period in the film where they are on the same page because their arcs intersect.  This is entertaining, but predictable.
                “The Wind That Shakes the Barley” is a good, but not great movie.  The pickings must have been slim at Cannes that year.  I enjoyed it and learned a lot from it.  It does a service to history and is entertaining at the same time.  Be aware that it is a bit on the depressing side.  Damian’s side did lose, after all.  Will it crack my 100 Best list?  Unlikely, but you should still watch it.

grade =  B+