I rushed to
see a movie today that I have been waiting more than eleven years for. Ever since 9/11/2001. For a few years, I had almost lost hope that
the subject would ever arise. Thank God
it finally came to pass. Then I had to
worry about how Hollywood would handle the inevitable film treatment(s). You know screenwriters immediately got to
work on a rush take on it. I really
wanted to “see” the death of the most evil man of my lifetime, but I know that
if inferior film comes out first, it poisons the waters for later takes. When I heard that Kathryn Bigelow and Mark
Boal (both of “The Hurt Locker”) were preparing a version, I felt a little more
confident. I need not have worried. The other productions can shut down. We now have the definitive retelling of the greatest
manhunt in history. It turns out that
manhunt was led by a woman.
The movie is amazing and is
built around one of the outstanding real-life heroines in cinema history. Jessica Chastain should win the Oscar for her
performance as Maya. She portrays the
CIA operative as obsessive and persevering (to the point of being a pain in the
ass for her superiors). Her evolution
from naïve to hard as nails in the world of black sites is a theme. How ironic that the actual role model will
not be able to reap the fame (at least not for a while, hopefully). Bigelow and Boal made a great decision to
concentrate on this woman and build up to the mission by showing the
frustrating quest to locate UBL (the movie does not dumb it down for the
current events-challenged masses).
Chastain is well-supported by a strong cast. It’s not all-star, but you’ll recognize many
solid performers. The biggest surprise
is Chris Pratt (from the wonderful “Parks and Recreation”) as a Navy SEAL. Informed choice, considering elite military types
often have good senses of humor. By the
way, there is also a major part for one of my favorite actresses- Jennifer Ehle
(the miniseries “Pride and Prejudice”).
I won’t give away the plot. The movie works on two levels. If you are like me and have a working
knowledge of the war on terrorism, it is exciting to see some key events
reenacted masterfully. It does help to
know the basics. The dialogue assumes that. There are numerous references to KSM (google
his ugly ass). I almost envy the
majority of Americans who will find the entire movie suspenseful because they
do not know what will happen next.
The movie opens chillingly with
a blank screen (no opening credits) and audio from phone calls from victims of
9/11. Just in case you needed to be
reminded about the stakes. It closes
with the mission. In between is a fascinating quest to locate the most wanted man on Earth. Bigelow throws in some shocking acts of terrorism to juice the narrative. The reenactment of mission is
mesmerizing even for those who know what will happen. The flight into Abbottabad has the best use of music that I can recall in
a scene like this. Not bombastic. I would best describe it as SEALish. The “assault” is a blend of POV and fly on
the wall cinematography. It is not
frenetic like in “Act of Valor” (a movie I love). You won’t feel like you are playing a first
person shooter. You will be on the edge of your seat.
Interestingly, the movie does
not do the cliché of describing the mission plan. After all those days of waiting (angrily tallied on her bosses window by Maya), we are suddenly thrust into the big night. This was a good decision for both the
informed and the historical illiterates.
It also does not flesh out the SEAL characters. However, small touches make it clear they are
not only heroes, but professionals.
There is an understated scene where Maya watches them play horse shoes
and is stunned to learn that they know they are going on the mission that very
night. Subtle, but brilliant. The movie also avoids the cliché of the corrupt
or clueless authorities. No Americans
are villains. It does take to task the
risk-averse, but they are portrayed as simply too careful. Then again, Maya is portrayed as an obsessed
bitch. Thank God she was! CIA Director Leon Panetta comes off well, but
there is little reference to Obama and none of George W. Bush. The movie does not lionize Obama for giving
the green light. It does not demonize
Muslims. In fact, a CIA official is
tellingly depicted on his prayer mat.
As far as accuracy, I could detect
nothing egregious. I have read
extensively on the subject. I read “SEAL
Target Geronimo” and the mission is basically as chronicled in that book. The movie does not add any explosions. It also does not sugar coat what happened in
that compound. Spoiler alert: there is no attempt to take UBL alive. As to the controversial depiction of torture
and the actionable results from inhumane interrogation, I would be surprised if
those types of things did not happen.
You may want to believe otherwise, but get your head out of the sand. It is a crying shame that the ostriches will
prevent this movie from a deserved Best Picture Oscar. It is a travesty that they have already
deprived Bigelow of a director nomination.
In conclusion, “Zero Dark Thirty”
tells the story many have been waiting to see.
It does it in a well-crafted way that does justice to history. It is better than “The Hurt Locker” and “Lincoln”. It will have its detractors and where you stand
on this is telling. I’m not sure if it
is a war movie, but whatever genre it falls into- it is outstanding.
grade = A
Oh boy... I call that a coincidence. I just published my review of the exact same movie. Only our reviews couldn't be more different...
ReplyDeleteThat is amazing. The timing and the fact our opinions are the opposite. If it wasn't for opinions, both of our blogs would not exist. Disagreeing is cool and in this case mostly reflects our different perspectives.
ReplyDeleteMin you, I thought it was interesting as I hadn't really followed the whole story... But I was disappointed because it's not a very imaginative movie. She could have made a documentary, if you know what I mean. I wouldn't want to make a movie like that. It didn't feel so creative.
ReplyDeleteBigelow has crafted a film which will keep audiences enrapt for ages to come.
ReplyDelete