Saturday, September 14, 2013

WAR MOVIE CHICK FLICK: Shining Through (1992)



                “Shining Through” is an espionage movie set in WWII Germany.  It is based on the novel by Susan Isaacs, but I have been informed that the plot is vastly different.  I’ll take the Internet’s word for that since, as you will deduce, I am very unlikely to read the book.  The movie was written and directed by David Seltzer.  He must be very proud because it cleaned up at the Razzies, winning for Worst Picture, Worst Director, and Worst Actress (Melanie Griffith).  It was nominated for Screenplay and Actor (Michael Douglas) – he was robbed!  In a why bother move, it was filmed mostly in Berlin and Potsdam.  You know, for authenticity!

                The movie opens decades after the war with Linda Voss (Griffith) being interviewed for a documentary about (I guess) great women spies of WWII.  I wonder if she will survive her mission deep into Nazi Germany.  Flashback to 1940.  Linda gets a job as a translator for an attorney named Leland (Douglas).  She speaks fluent German because her father was a German Jew.  In fact, she still has relatives hiding in Berlin.  Linda has seen enough war movies (she’s a buff!) to figure out Leland is a spy.  She often refers to war movies like “The Fighting 69th” starring Cary Grant.   (A movie not starring Grant and not about spying, but don’t bother Seltzer with that.)

I speak German, can I please be a spy?
                Opposites attract as Linda is feisty and Leland is foresty (he acts like a tree).  Romantic music tells us it’s bedtime.  Guys, try to make it this far into the movie and not just to win a Klondike bar.  (Hint:  this is one of only thirteen movies where Griffith shows her Melanies.  I am serious about research.)  When war breaks out Leland shows up in his OSS uniform and there is a Casablanca-like parting at an airport.  Linda is jilted for her country.  Six months later, Leland reappears on the arms of a bimbo at a dance Linda is moping at.  AWKWARD.  She uses a woman’s ultimate weapon (tears)  to get him to admit he was in love with her.  She accepts that admission although it is given while being eye-water tortured (and this guy is a spy?).  He rehires her because he does not want to see that weapon deployed again.

Casablanca, it ain't!
              
  The Germans are developing a bomb that can fly by itself.  It will carry women’s tears.  Just kidding.  Someone needs to steal the plans.  Is there anyone available that speaks German, but has no spy experience?  Seems like a job for super-spy Leland, but he doesn’t speak German.  Drat!  The feisty Linda twists his arm and gets the gig.  She is hooked up with an agent called “Sunflower” (John Geilgud) who is skeptical because he has a brain.  He puts her in contact with a vivacious, overfriendly (oh, oh) German girl named Margrete (Joely Richardson) who is anti-Nazi for no discernible reason.

a hot, blonde Nazi in a red dress with a gun
                Linda gets a position as the main cook in the target Nazi’s home and her first job is a major dinner party for a Nazi bigwig.  Add not knowing how to cook to her not knowing how to spy resume.  She spills soup on the guest of honor Col. Dietrich (Liam Neeson).  (In Nazi Germany, the main chef was required to also serve the meal apparently.)  She is sacked, but lucky for her Dietrich is one of those creepy Nazi’s that likes incompetent people to spill soup on them.  He hires her as the nanny for his precious children.  She can’t contact Leland to tell him about her big steaming pile of luck, but he finds out when he sees her in the crowd of a German newsreel.  (No she is not flashing her Melanies, alas.)

                Linda takes the two kids to the zoo, but has the ulterior motive of finding her relatives.  The kids won’t mention a little side trip to a scary deserted room, will they?  Linda’s discovery that her relatives are no longer in hiding (for a bad reason) is followed by a run through a bombing raid featuring a runaway zebra.  Cinematic art!  When they return home, she is not shot in the head by Dietrich.  This gives her time to locate the secret room where Dietrich keeps his super-secret flying bomb plans.  It’s so secret he hides the key above the door.  Being an ace spy, she finds the key and photographs the plans and almost gets caught, of course.

                Dietrich takes her to the opera dressed like his dead wife.  Leland had never taken her to the opera.  It’s unclear what that is supposed to mean.  She is accidentally ratted out by Margrete’s mother. Back at the mansion she sees Dietrich with a gun and decides his incredible credulity has finally snapped.  She flees in her gown, hops on the zebra and goes to her BFF Margrete’s house.  Sorry, no zebra.  She runs the ten miles. 

                Margrete is a Nazi double agent!  And she had been so nice.  Cheater!  She stalks Linda, who not having gone to spy school, is very poor at hiding.  Wait, she must have seen Joel Chandler in the famous wind mill scene in “Foreign Correspondent”.  Anyway, she gets shot twice in the stomach before she miraculously kills Margrete.  Is that the Gestapo banging at the door?  Linda escapes (actually falls) down the laundry chute after throwing her purse out the window to make the bad guys think she fled.  It's easy to fool the Gestapo.

                Meanwhile, the intrepid Leland has arrived in Berlin disguised as a Nazi officer and hoping like hell no one expects him to speak German.  (Who has time to learn a language while a war is going on?!)  He finds her with the laundry and in a “Weekend at Bernie’s” homage takes her to the train station and puts her on a train to Switzerland.  Did I mention she has two bullets in the stomach?  At the border check point, the I-have-a-neck-wound-so-I-can't-talk gesturing Leland has to open fire on skeptical guards and then carries Linda over the border line while being shot in the back twice.  Action - finally checked off.  They both die of their mortal injuries.  Sad, but realistic.  But wait, how was she able to do the interview?  Well, it must be tough recalling the death of her lover.  But wait, who is that handsomely grey man with her two children?  As I’m sure you already know, the microfilm she brought back hidden in her glove resulted in the bombing of Peenemunde and victory for the Allies in WWII.

I'll shoot anyone who tries to keep me in this movie
RACHELLE:  The movie was far-fetched from the beginning with over the top acting from all the actors—a major disappointment because I like Michael Douglas and Melanie Griffith.  The plot required you to suspend all logical, realistic belief and thinking.  The music was too dramatic throughout the movie.  I always like happy endings, but when Michael Douglas looks like he has been riddled with bullets, once again reality is suspended to achieve that happy ending.

KEVIN:  I remember the critical drubbing the movie took when it came out and the plot synopsis also did not make me keen to see it.  It seemed far-fetched that Melanie Griffith could go behind enemy lines to win the war.  Plus I knew it was a romance so it managed to slip past me for twenty years.  This blog has caused me to give some movies a second chance.  I have found invariably that my first impressions of movies I either avoided or did not like were correct the first time around.  This movie starts with a ridiculous premise and piles on implausibilities.  Although it could potentially have been entertaining, it would have taken a lot to overcome the unbelievable plot.  Nothing that happens in the movie could have occurred.  For instance, the German border with Switzerland was closed during the war so Linda and Leland could not have gotten into Germany by train.  Worse, there are parts that make no sense. 

                Perhaps if the acting had been stellar.  It is far from it.  Griffith never comes close to making her character anything but a joke.  In fact, the movie would have worked better as a comedy.   But the big problem is Douglas.  He sleep-walks through the film.  There is no chemistry between the two.  Barzman’s script deserves a lot of the blame.  Tampering with the book was probably not a good idea.  The flashback decision was a poor one because it reduced the suspense of the ending.  Throwing in the Holocaust references was cheap, but had the positive effect of enlightening Griffith about that tragedy.  Unbelievably, the 41 year old actress was not familiar with the plight of European Jews before making the movie!  I guess I should excuse her because I thought I knew a lot about WWII but I did not know the raid on Peenemunde was due to a female non-spy smuggling microfilm and two bullets into Switzerland by train.

grades:

RACHELLE = D- 

KEVIN =  F 
 
 

Monday, September 9, 2013

FORGOTTEN GEM? Play Dirty (1969)



                In 1969, a movie entitled “Play Dirty” attempted to outdirty the “Dirty Dozen”.  It makes no bones about its goal – hell, it has “dirty” in the title!  The movie goes beyond its predecessor in its antiwar theme and seems to try to rectify the sheen of adventure that pervades TDD.  The film is set in North Africa in WWII.  It is firmly in the suicide mission subgenre.  Picking up on the “Dirty Dozen” twist of comprising the unit of criminals, “Play Dirty” creates a multi-national unit of specialists who happen to be slimeballs. 

                The mission is to go 400 miles behind enemy lines  to attack one of Rommel’s fuel depots.  A British petroleum engineer named Douglas (Michael Caine) is dragooned by a British Col. Masters (Nigel Green) into leading the mission.  His reluctant second is a convicted criminal named Leech (Nigel Davenport).  Naturally they do not get along as Douglas believes there are rules in warfare.  How adorable!  The dirty half dozen consists of assorted low-lives with no redeeming qualities (unlike some of the Dirty Dozen) including two half-wit Arab homosexuals.  Kudos (?) for going way outside the box for a 1969 war movie.  This being a screw the Old School movie, the mission is not as advertised.  Higher command is using the squad as a diversion for the real attack force which will follow in its wake.

Once upon a time, Michael Caine was a bad ass
                Disguised as Italians, our motley crew heads into the desert.  There is an interesting set piece where they have to get their vehicles up a cliff by hoisting them.  As they finish this task, they have a grandstand view of the slaughter of the “real heroes” in the valley below.  The Germans eliminate this unit with extreme prejudice.  Leech prevents Douglas from intervening.  Douglas:  “You play dirty.”  Leech:  “I play safe.”  One of these guys is going to move over to the other way of thinking by the end of the movie.  Guess which.  (Hint:  this movie was made in the late 1960s.)

                There are no problems reaching the supply depot.  Just kidding.  One of the Arabs is wounded by a mine.  They ambush an ambulance.  The German nurse puts up a good fight until Leech knocks her out.  “Don’t you know how to treat a lady?”  Feminists will love this movie.  Later, three of the men attempt to rape the nurse.  The wounded guy shoots one of them in the ass.  Chivalry is not dead.

                They reach the objective and infiltrate through a mine field during a sand storm.  Get ready for explosions.  Crap, it’s a fake site.  What an unfulfilling movie.  But wait, Douglas insists they move on to destroy a fuel dump.  Pheww!  Let’s go get some unit members killed so I can win my bet on how many survive.

                The brass is not happy with this initiative.  Monty will need that fuel.  They inform the Germans that our intrepid scumbags are coming.  The group (disguised as German soldiers) walk into a trap but still manage to set off numerous explosions.  Leech sacrifices the others so he and Douglas can survive.  They are too important to the war effort.  Well, at least two survived the mission.  Technically.  When you make your bets on how many will survive in this movie make sure you specify whether you are referring to surviving the mission or surviving to the end of the movie.


                “Play Dirty” is loosely based on history.  Masters could be based on Vladimir “Popski” Peniakoff.  Popski was an adventurer who was given command of a special forces group which became known as Popski’s Private Army.  Using jeeps it would go behind enemy lines to raid Afrika Korps fuel dumps in advance of Montgomery’s 8th Army after the Battle of El Alamein.  The unit had a reputation for cautious daring and suffered low casualties. 

                The “Dirty Dozen” was a necessary attempt to desanitize the suicide mission subgenre by populating the unit with criminal-types.  “Play Dirty” pushes the envelope by making the anti-heroes evil and the mission unnecessary.  The brass is also pushed out to cynical manipulators.  They go from being jerks to assholes.  More importantly, in TDD you could say that as bad as the dozen were, at least the Nazis they killed were worse.  That is not the case in this movie, Leech and crew are more evil than the Germans.  Trust me, there is no rooting for Jefferson moment in this film.

                The plot takes a while to get to any action, but the action provided is fairly intense and suspenseful.  The violence is not particularly graphic which puts the movie in the transition period between Old School and VioLingo.  There is little character development beyond Douglas and Leech.  We don’t care about any of the other members other than not caring if they get killed.  The acting is substandard.  The cast is the polar opposite of TDD.  Only Caine is noteworthy.  The two leads underplay their roles.  The enemy is faceless.

                In conclusion, “Play Dirty” is a shameless rip-off of “The Dirty Dozen”, but unfortunately it is not a guilty pleasure.  The film has its fans and some unbelievably find it superior to TDD.  If you love subversion and hate the military , you might like it.  If you are a war movie lover, it is interesting to see how far the pendulum swung from “The Guns of Navarone”.  It has to be viewed as a misfire creatively and financially.  It strikes me as almost a stunt.  It certainly would have worked better as a parody.  Which reminds me, there is virtually no humor in the movie (unless you find women being cold-cocked and Arab homosexuality to be funny).  Even during the Vietnam War, a film with no positive characters and such a cynical attitude seems too negative.  Getting back to my pendulum metaphor, look at “Inglorious Basterds”.  Even Quentin Tarantino did not go as far as “Play Dirty”.
grade =  D

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Kelly's Heroes (1970)



            “Kelly’s Heroes” is part of the commando mission subgenre that includes “Guns of Navarone” (1961), “The Dirty Dozen” (1967), and “Where Eagles Dare” (1968).  It put a new spin on the subgenre by adding a heavy dose of humor.  It also added a heist element to the plot.  It was directed by Brian Hutton and filmed in Yugoslavia to take advantage of the Yugoslavian army’s Sherman and T-34 tanks.  The T-34s were modified to look like Tigers.  The amount of military hardware appearing in the film is truly impressive.  It has an all-star cast led by Clint Eastwood who had made “Where Eagles Dare” with Hutton two years earlier.  Telly Savalas had appeared in “The Dirty Dozen”.  Donald Sutherland had also starred in that movie and made “MASH” the same year as KH.  1970 was a great year for war movies as “Patton” was also released that year.  Like “MASH”, KH is set in one war, but commenting on another time period.  “Kelly’s Heroes” has obvious references to the Vietnam War and the sixties.  We get some portent of this with the opening song which is the ridiculously out of place “Burning Bridges”.  Listen to the lyrics and explain what the hell they have to do with the movie. 
 
                “Kelly’s Heroes” was set in 1944 France.  The 35th Infantry Division is fighting outside Nancy.  Pvt. Kelly (Eastwood) is in a jeep in the middle of a German force.  He narrowly escapes when they recognize him (not the jeep!) and gets to American lines with a captured German colonel.  A drink fueled interrogation of the colonel reveals that the German’s have hidden $16 million of gold bars in a bank thirty miles behind enemy lines.  Being an American, greed immediately takes precedence over patriotism, duty, yadda yadda yadda.  Kelly will need help so he enlists a rifle squad of equally greedy individuals.  Their sergeant, Big Joe (Savalas), reluctantly goes along due to peer pressure.
 
                Our anti-heroes will need lots of support.  They bring a supply sergeant / fence named Crap Game (Don Rickles) on board.  They get tank support by way of a commune of Shermans led by one of the most anachronistic characters in war movie history.  Odd Ball (Sutherland) is a hippie.  He and his men say things like “negative waves”, “dig”, and “baby”.  The tanks are rigged up with loudspeakers to blast music (ala the helicopters in “Apocalypse Now”).   Odd Ball is so out of time that it’s pointless to target the anachronisms.  Just roll with it.
 
                The mission begins as a lark, but things get serious when a friendly fighter plane attacks Kelly and his crew destroying their vehicles and much of their equipment.  To remind us the movie is only partly a comedy there is a scene involving a mine field that results in some poignant deaths among the group.  Guys don’t mind shedding some tears if it is balanced with lots of explosions.  For instance, Odd Ball’s three tanks attack a rail way station and to the blare of country music proceed to blast the crap out of the Germans.
One is a hippie and the other eats hippies for breakfast
 
                Since this is a 1970 movie, there must be a subplot involving the cluelessness of the brass (unless they are George Patton).  Gen. Colt (Carroll O’Connor) has been chafing over lack of forward momentum until he finds out about this small unit that has broken through enemy lines.  He can’t wait to pin medals on these courageous GIs and of course take credit for their success.  (If the movie was not made at the same time as “Patton”, you would swear Colt is a parody of Patton.)  Now Kelly and crew are racing to the gold and racing from the medal pinnings.
 
                The squad and the tanks meet up outside the town with the bank.  Besides a German garrison to provide plenty of Germans to kill, there are three Tiger tanks for the Shermans to duel with.  All hell breaks loose and in a twist of the caper aspect of the film, it’s not after they rob the bank.  It comes down to a showdown with the remaining Tiger and its Aryan commander.  In an homage to Eastwood’s spaghetti westerns, Kelly, Big Joe, and Odd Ball come forward (sans white flag) to parley with the Nazi.  It turns out Nazis can put greed before their country also.  We’re all rich now!  Don Rickles ad libs “you win a cookie”.  Odd Ball rides off in the Tiger.  Good luck returning to American lines with your gold!  Don’t shoot,  P-47s - we're AWOL, thieving American hippies.
 
                KH is very entertaining if you can suspend disbelief and it winkingly expects you to.  It is a deft blend of action, suspense, and humor.  It’s the humor that separates it from its peers.  It is populated with colorful characters and the casting is masterful.  You have actors who could not crack a smile to save their lives (Eastwood and Savalas) paired with sitcom stars (Rickles and O’Connor).  Throw in Sutherland, a counterculture icon, who the audience would assume is playing himself.  Dropping a hippie into a WWII movie is so bizarre it works.  The acting is good across the board and they appear to be having fun. 
the high, the laconic, and the bald
 
                The plot is no more far-fetched than similar action films and the flow between action and movement is
good.  The violence is over the top, but realistic to WWII.  There are some excellent set pieces.  In fact, some of the themes are appropriate for a standard war film.  The soldiers are war weary.  There are incidents of the “fog of war”.  The movie naturally adds the incompetence of command angle.  What is a little outside the box is the theme of greed trumping survival instincts.  That is not the motivation in any of the other members of the subgenre.

                How does it stack up with the others of its subgenre?  It’s in the upper half.

1.  Where Eagles Dare
2.  Inglorious Basterds
3.  Kelly’s Heroes
4.  The Dirty Dozen
5.  The Guns of Navarone
6.  The Eagle Has Landed
7.  The Devil's Brigade
 
                Does it crack the 100 Best?  Probably.
 
grade =  B+
 
 

Monday, September 2, 2013

AUGUST WAR MOVIE LEADERSHIP WATCHALONG: Lawrence of Arabia



1.  What characteristics of a great military leader did Lawrence have?

         Based on the movie, the most obvious characteristic is inspirational motivation.  The man oozed charisma.  His magnetic personality even brought disparate tribes under his sway.  He also showed a lot of moral courage.  This is the ability to send men to their deaths for the greater cause,  he exemplified this when he executed his friend in order to prevent a blood feud and the disintegration of the alliance.

        Although it's not always a good idea for a leader to do this, Lawrence certainly believed in leading by example.  He was in the front of the raids on the railway.  This was crucial in gaining the respect of his Arab warriors.  His willingness to endure what his men endured has the same effect.  In fact, Lawrence went beyond anything his men had to endure.

2.  What were his weaknesses as a commander?

        Lawrence got too personally involved in his cause.  He was torn between his home country and his dream of a new Arab nation.  This led to tremendous feelings of guilt when it turned out the dream was quashed by Britain's self-interest.

       Lawrence is reminiscent of Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now" in that he went native and it had a destabilizing effect on him.  He does not go insane like Kurtz did, but instead he is distressed by being caught between two worlds.  In a sense, Lawrence showed moral courage in his command decisions, but not personally.  He never fully committed to either world. 

September:  Letters from Iwo Jima

What leadership characteristics did General Kuribayashi exhibit?