VS.
PLOT: “All Quiet…” is a faithful rendering of the most
famous war novel. This makes the plot
outstanding. For those of you who are
reading this from another planet, the movie is the story of Paul Baumer and his
mates as they try to survive on the Western Front. Paul goes from naïve schoolboy to cynical
veteran. The men go through boot camp
and then it’s off to the front to experience what the war is really like. Under the tutelage of a wizened old vet, Paul
and the boys learn the ropes. Along the
way they find out that war sucks and few survive. It’s heart-felt and heart-breaking. It has several iconic combat scenes. GRADE - A+
“Private Peaceful” is based on a young adult
novel. It is the tale of two brothers
and the girl they both love. She chooses
the older Charlie which breaks Tommo’s heart.
The war separates the couple, but reunites the brothers. Tommo and Charlie are lower class lads who go
off to the Western Front where they are harassed by evil sergeant Hanley. He is
a stock villain who does everything but twirl his mustache. The plot builds to the execution of one of
the boys for disobeying orders. It
concludes with a trite twist ending. GRADE
- C+
FIRST
QUARTER SCORE: All Quiet -
10 Peaceful - 7
ACTING: The only real flaw in “All Quiet” is in the
acting. The cast is not special. Lew Ayres was not a big star and did not get
top billing. His performance is much too
overwrought. Top billing went to Louis
Wolheim who played Kat. He and Slim Summerville
(Tjaden) are the only main actors who don’t chew scenery. There are several moments in the film where
the acting causes giggles. Although a
talkie, the film is distinctly silent in its acting. Even Ayres, who became a star from his role as
Paul, is cringe-inducing at times. GRADE
- C
“Private Peaceful” stars the up and coming Jack
O’Connell as Charlie and he brings a lot of charisma to the role. The rest of the cast is not well known, but they
are fine. John Lynch foams at the mouth
as the despicable Hanley, but the role was written for that. GRADE - C
HALFTIME
SCORE: All Quiet -
16 Peaceful - 13
COMBAT: It may surprise many that “All Quiet” has only 11
minutes of combat. The quality is high, however. The big set piece trench warfare scene is a
classic. It is the best at showing the
back and forth of trench assaults. The
French evict them in spite of their machine guns and rifle fire, they retreat
to their reserve trench, a barrage forces the French back, the Germans
counterattack and take the French trench, but they withdraw and everyone is
back where they started from! The scene
features some vicious hand-to-hand fighting and one indelible shot of severed
hands on the barbed wire. Combat is
secondary to the hardships and rare moments of humanity that Paul and the
others undergo. GRADE - B
“Private Peaceful” has only 5 minutes of combat and
what there is is small scale. It is also
unrealistically staged. The no man’s
land is merely a field. No shell
craters. No reason to scare the
kiddies. Besides, it’s a tale of two
brothers and their girl friend. The only
part combat plays is to set up the court-martial. You would think it was a play. GRADE - D
THIRD
QUARTER SCORE: All Quiet -
24 Peaceful - 18
ANTI-WAR: “All Quiet” is based on the most famous antiwar novel
ever written. And the movie surely
brings the vibe to the silver screen.
This theme that the war was a terrible mistake kicks in from the very
first scene and is consistently permeating the film throughout even the home
front scene. The movie includes Paul’s
stay in the hospital which is another form of horror. The body count is reflective of an anti-war
movie. The anti-command sub-theme is
exemplified by the Himmelstoss character.
By the way, Lew Ayres became a conscientious objector in WWII due to his
involvement in the movie. GRADE
- A+
“Private Peaceful” is meant to be anti-war in a
lecturing sort of way. Being aimed at a
young audience, the theme is simplified and unsubtle. The movie does not really show the horrors of
trench warfare. The big tear-jerking
moment is the result of villainy that could have been found in civilian
life. If anything, the movie is more
anti-upper class. The Peaceful family is
trod upon by their local landlord. GRADE
- C
FINAL
SCORE: All Quiet - 34
Private
Peaceful - 24
MATCH
ANALYSIS: Hey, I had to go
through the motions, okay? This was
truly a mismatch. It was a lightweight
up against a heavyweight and it got pummeled.
“All Quiet” is a classic that is arguably still the best WWI movie ever
made. “Private Peaceful” will be
forgotten soon. Not that it was the 16th
best movie in the tournament. There were
definitely worse contenders.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please fell free to comment. I would love to hear what you think and will respond.