VS.
PLOT:
“Paths of Glory” is a court room
(court-martial) drama set on the Western Front in 1916. Although a fictional tale, it realistically
portrays the state of the French army at the time and the incompetent and
merciless leadership of the high command.
A French unit is forced to make a suicidal attack by a general seeking a
promotion. When the attack predictably
fails, he insists on putting three random soldiers on trial for cowardice. Their humane commanding officer defends them
in the trial. The plot is
outstanding. Although mainly
concentrating on the trial, it does manage to set the scenario up with one of
the great combat scenes as the unit makes its futile assault across a very
realistic no man’s land. Never have the
machinations of WWI commanders been portrayed as perceptively. GRADE - A+
“Passchendaele”
is a romance set in WWI. A Canadian
soldier performs heroically on the Western Front, but his post traumatic stress
disorder lands him back in Canada on recruitment duty. He falls in love with a nurse. In a parallel plot line, her brother is
attempting to get himself sent to the front partly to win the hand of a local
girl. When he succeeds, the hero goes
back to watch over him. The nurse also
ends up near the front lines.
“Passchendaele” is obviously not a true story as it bends itself into a
pretzel to facilitate the plot arc. It
is very unrealistic, but does feature a balls to the wall combat scene at the
end. GRADE - C+
FIRST QUARTER SCORE: Paths
- 10 Passchendaele - 7
“Passchendaele” was written, directed, and starred in
by Paul Gross. Gross made a name for
himself in the cult show “Due North” and brings some charisma to the role. He’s no Kirk Douglas, but he is not bad. The rest of the cast is far from stellar. Credit is due for keeping a straight face
through some of the ludicrous aspects of the plot. Although the movie was the most expensive
Canadian production up to that time, it does not show in the acting.
GRADE - C+
HALFTIME
SCORE: Paths - 20 Passchendaele - 14
COMBAT: “Paths of Glory” is not a combat movie. It only has about seven minutes of
combat. However, it uses two combat
scenes to set up the court-martial. The
first is a night raid that is short on action, but is crucial for character
development. The highlight of the movie
is the iconic assault through no man’s land.
Stanley Kubrick is at his best in this fabulous scene. The bombardment effects are noisily
realistic. The camera tracks Dax as he
leads his men through the shell-cratered landscape. It is probably the most authentic rendering
of the doomed assaults associated with the war.
I show it every year in class to prepare my students for their trench
letter assignment. Watching the scene
leaves no doubt as to why the French army would face a mutiny problem. GRADE - A
“Passchendaele” seems to have realized that it needed
to compensate for its lame romance with some high octane action. It has a total of 21 minutes of combat which
puts it among the leaders in that category of quantity. Surprisingly, the quality is not bad. The final battle goes on for fifteen minutes
and is graphic if cartoonish. It is in
the style of “Saving Private Ryan”.
There is even a bout of hand-to-hand with any weapons available. You won’t be eating your popcorn during this
scene. It is far from realistic, but
entertaining for the guys who brought their chicks to see a romance. Hell, the Germans charge into no man’s land
to meet the Canadians! The movie is
really strong on artillery fire, but so are most WWI movies. GRADE - B
THIRD
QUARTER SCORE: Paths -
29 Passchendaele - 22
ANTI-WAR: Have you seen “Paths of Glory”? If so, you know where this is going. Some WWI movies are famous for the Nazis
banning them. “Paths” was not banned in
France, but the French government discouraged its debut there for two decades.
It is easy to see why. The movie is an
indictment of the French brass that crassly sent thousands to their deaths
while sipping claret in their chateaus.
The movie is more anti-command than anti-war. No major character dies in combat. It is the best movie ever made to show how
the war was made horrific not only by the use of modern weaponry, but this was
compounded by incompetent, uncaring generals who refused to adjust tactics to
the realities of trench warfare. GRADE
- A+
“Passchedaele” is not the first WWI movie that comes
to mind when you think of war criticism.
However, it actually is not just a feel-blood kind of movie. The main character is cynical and only fights
for love of Sarah. The movie makes a
point of showing the naivete of the new recruits and the recruiting head is a
main villain. The pressure to join the
adventure is a theme. The ending is
heart-tugging. GRADE - A
FINAL
SCORE: Paths -
39
Passchendaele - 31
MATCH
ANALYSIS: Everyone saw this
outcome from a mile away. “Paths” will
be a strong contender for the championship and is one of the all-time great war
movies. “Passchendaele” is a relatively
unknown movie that had no pretensions to grandeur. I’m sure it was just happy to make the
tournament. It put up a decent fight,
but never stood a chance.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please fell free to comment. I would love to hear what you think and will respond.