Sunday, December 19, 2010

MODERN CLASSIC? "Restrepo"

    
     “Restrepo” is the movie companion to the acclaimed best seller “War” by Sebastian Junger. Junger was a reporter who embedded with an infantry platoon in Afghanistan in 2007-8 to get an eyewitness look at the fighting. What came out of his experience is a grunts-eye view of the war that takes the viewer into a very foreign world where American boys are fighting a forgotten war. If you feel guilty about having forgotten about their sacrifices or if you want to know what is going on over there, you should watch this outstanding documentary.


     The movie is seen through the eyes of the cameramen (Junger and Tim Hetherington) who lived with the soldiers interspersed with frequent interviews with the troops after they got back. The men belong to the Second Platoon, Battle Company, 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment which was sent to the most dangerous place in Afghanistan – the Kerengal Valley. They were deployed for 15 months and three of them did not come back including Juan “Doc” Restrepo. Their mission was to provide security for a road-building project that would benefit the obviously ungrateful residents. But based on the book and film, it is apparent their mission was to deprive the Taliban of control of the valley and kill as many of them in the process as possible.

     The movie is intense and personal. You have to admire the cameraman who was right there with the soldiers when they were taking fire. In fact, early in the movie we get an inside the Humvee view of what it is like to be blown up by an IED. Most of the action takes place at an outpost named after their beloved medic Restrepo. The commander named Kearny comes off as an intelligent officer who is trying to rectify mistakes made by the previous leadership which now make it harder to win “hearts and minds”. His decision to establish Outpost Restrepo turns the tide in the valley. (In a postscript, it is revealed that after all the effort in the area, the Army abandoned the valley. See “Hamburger Hill”.)

     Here are some of the things you will learn: 1. Afghanistan is a beautiful country with some truly ugly men. 2. The volunteer army concept is working. These boys are much more motivated than Vietnam War soldiers filmed under similar circumstances in 1969 would have been. 3. One of our main tactics is to make contact by drawing enemy fire. Sucks to be the guy who draws the fire. 4. If you want Americans to expend one thousand rounds, fire a few shots into their compound. 5. Life in an outpost can be so boring that you look forward to fire-fights. One soldier described fire-fights as like crack. 6. We are spending billions of dollars in Afghanistan, but we won’t pay for a farmer’s cow that “wandered into the barbed wire” and became steak. 7. Soldiers in Afghanistan do not curse as much as I thought. 8. This country and our army are not prepared mentally for losses comparable to Vietnam, much less WWII. The platoon lost “only” three men in 15 months, but because of the bonding, the deaths were gut-wrenching. 9. Being reasonable with Afghani elders is probably not going to work. 10. It is possible to make a realistic, informative movie about the war in Afghanistan without taking a political stand.


video

2 comments:

  1. I was curious to watch this and am still after reading your review. I watched the Russian The 9th Company a while back and my take home message was: no one will be able to conquer Afghanistan... The Russians would know... How is it compared to the book?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I watched 9th Company a while back and should be posting on it soon. It makes a good companion to Restrepo. I think if our military had watched 9th Company before getting involved in Afgahnistan, we could have avoided some mistakes and overconfidence. It's that American hubris again. However, what we are facing in Afghanistan is not nearly as bad as what the Soviets faced. We have a better chance of being successful because our goals are more realistic than theirs, our army is better, our technology (Predator drones, protection for helicopters) is better, and we do not have a superpower aiding the enemy. Still, I am not optimistic about the long-term prospects. It remionds me a lot of Vietnam, in that we are trying to prop up an unpopular, inefficient, corrupt government. But by far the most scary thing is that we plan to turn things over to the Afghani army. As much grief as the ARVN got, it was ten times better than the Afghani army will be and you see what happened in Vietnam after we pulled out.
    The movie is basically the book on film. He naturally is more opinionated in the book and the book is more about him whereas the movie is all about the soldiers. They make for a great pairing.

    ReplyDelete

Please fell free to comment. I would love to hear what you think and will respond.