Tuesday, October 15, 2013

CLASSIC or ANTIQUE? “Battle Circus” (1953)


 
                “Battle Circus” is a Korean War movie released in 1953.  It was written and directed by Richard Brooks (“Take the High Ground”).  The movie is about a MASH unit and was originally entitled “MASH 66”.  The studio worried people would think it was about potatoes.  Instead a title was developed that reflected the circus atmosphere and tents of a Mobile Hospital.  The technical adviser had operated a MASH unit in Korea so the operation was accurate.  Humphrey Bogart was paid $250,000, but that princely sum did not keep him from regretting making the film.  The fact that he burned his thumb during a scene where he destroys papers before a retreat did not increase his enthusiasm.  The scene was left in the film.  At least he got decent reviews.  His co-star June Allyson was lambasted by the press.  So much for broadening her resume beyond “the girl next door”.

                “Battle Circus” is a “story about the indominable human spirit…”  It is set in an unspecified part of the Korean War, but based on the constant bugging out it would seem to be the first year.  The set looks like a MASH unit.  In other words, you’ll recognize “MASH” the movie and TV show.  There are the iconic tents and the helicopters bringing in the wounded (the movie was partly filmed at Camp Pickett, Virginia where the MASH units were trained).  We are introduced to the dangers of military medical care through a ridiculous strafing attack on the unit.  Using actual footage – of a USAF F-86!  Apparently the director did not give a crap about our intelligence level.  By the way, I would be surprised if there were any MIG strafings of hospitals in the entire war.

June finds out her make-up kit was left behind
                A cherry nurse arrives named Ruth (Allyson).  The hard drinking surgeon Maj. Webbe (Bogart) takes an immediate lusting for her.  They immediately begin the Hollywood process of hooking up.  This involves embarrassing pick-up lines by Webbe that would have Hawkeye Pierce gagging.  Plus Webbe is about as subtle as a kick in the stomach.  Ruth is very protective of her female virtue – for about five minutes.  That’s how long it takes the wolf in scrubs to get her to lower her surgical mask.  Soon she is the aggressor and madly (as in insanely) in love with him.

                It’s not all love in war.  Webbe saves a little Korean boys life by performing open heart surgery.  He is an ace surgeon and an ace drunk.  His drinking gets him in trouble with his superior.  In the obligatory carpet calling confrontation, Webbe makes a bizarrely contemporary comment about the “three world wars in our lifetime”.  How did I miss one?  I assume the screenwriters are referring to the Cold War as WWIII, but I thought that was only a recent bit of historical revisionism. 
looks just like a real war photo, doesn't it?

                Allyson gets to show off her serious acting chops (or lack thereof) in a silly scene where she talks down an enemy prisoner welding a grenade during an operation.  There are no subtitles but I’m pretty sure he is upset with the romance.  It appears that this naïve newbie has developed into a battle-hardened caregiver.  The movie closes with one last bug-out as the unit has to escape through enemy lines under artillery fire.  The nurses get separated from the doctors.  I mean Bogart gets separated from Allyson.  Will they have a loving reunion?  You’ll have to watch the movie.

listen kid, I can get my make-up guy to
make you look like you're in a war,too
                This is a strange movie.  It is part sappy romance and part realistic depiction of the workings of a MASH unit.  The look of the unit is real and the activities seem authentic.  The bug-outs are appropriate for that stage of the war.  The use of helicopters is well done.  All this effort is diluted by the romance half.  It would be like MASH bombing in the comedy sphere.  The two leads have little chemistry.  Bogart looks too old for the role.  Their dialogue is cringe-worthy.  No couple talks like that in real life.  Plus the arc of the romance defies reality.  Ruth goes from skeptical to stalking in the bat of an eyelash.  Of course, the actors are not helped by the script.  There is a painful scene where they wallow in a mud puddle.  Hilarious not.  This is the only time in the film that Allyson is not well-dressed, well-made up, amd well-coiffed.  At least the doctors sweat a little in the operating room.

                In spite of my carping, the movie is not that bad.  Aside from the elephantine cliché of a romance, the movie has some interesting twists.  The enemy is not demonized.  The movie is nurse-centric as oppsed to concentrating on the male doctors.  The film does a good job commemorating the role of the MASH units.

                Classic or antique?  Neither.

grade =  C 

Sunday, October 6, 2013

LIVE: Objective, Burma! (1945)



starring Errol “the George Clooney of the 1940s” Flynn /  directed by Raoul Walsh  /  two technical advisers  /  opens with stirring music  /  quote from Stilwell:  I got my assed kicked out of Burma, but I’ll be back  /  narration over actual footage -  Stilwell, Merrill  /  the actor playing Stilwell looks like an old hillbilly – he rolls his own cigarette and then puts it in a FDResque cigarette holder  /  EF is Capt. Nelson, paratrooper leader extraordinaire  /  the men are bathing – hey, there is a naked man’s ass!  is this a 40s movie?  /  “Quit waving your teeth” – oh, snap!  /  “You’re khaki-whacki” – double snap!  /  mission:  go behind enemy lines to destroy a radar station and make a crucial contribution to winning the war  /  a news correspondent (a la Ernie Pyle) named Williams is coming along – Nelson points out he is old and will not be able to hang, but okay  /  okay soldier banter  /  Nelson checks his men's gear before boarding the C-47 – he cares  /  close-ups on the plane  /  good cinematography on the jumps – no “Geronimos”  /  no one breaks their neck landing in a tree  /  lots of jungle noises – is this a Tarzan movie?  /  continuous music score sets the mood, but well  /  little talking – good noise discipline, but the enemy could hear the music from one hundred miles away  /  they reach the target with no problems – Nelson draws the plan up in the dirt  /  suspense builds as they sneak up;  Nelson pulls a grenade pin with his teeth;  short slaughter of the Japanese;  casualties:  Japanese – all dead (no wounded), Americans – not a scratch  /  that seemed too easy, what is left in this movie?  could there be some complications in getting home?  /  more humping through the boonies  /  Nelson talks to his BFF about their next leave thus dooming one of them to death  /  waiting for pick up – what a boring movie!  oh, oh here come the Japs and here starts the epic running away  /  they’ll have to walk out – it can’t be done!  /  another break for banter -  not lame  /  Nelson divides the unit into two groups - because 36 men are too much for any overwhelming Japanese force?  WTF;  theory: Nelson had seen Spencer Tracy in “Northwest Passage” do the exact same thing;  we’ll call them the EF half and the doomed non-EF half  /  “You ain’t just whistlin’ Dixie, brother”  /  “When you’re dealing with monkeys [the Japs], you gotta expect some wrenches” – racist, but awesome line  /  only two survivors arrive at the rendezvous with the non-EF half  / now we’re wading (note to producers of “Merrill’s Marauders”)  /  a Burmese village –  they find the mutilated bodies of the survivors of the ambushed non-EF half – we see their feet and take EF’s face’s word for how horrible the rest of their body’s are;  Nelson’s future leave partner begs him to kill him;  Williams rants about wiping all the monkeys off the face of the Earth – the audience agrees  /  the Japs arrive – the Americans set off a grenade booby trap (the Viet Cong watched this movie in training);  touchdown signaling deaths;  good action; run away, again  /  new orders via walkie talkie communication with a C-47 (can you do that?) – go North, young men;  WTF – well, orders are orders  /  “If your aunt had a beard, she’d be your uncle”  /  air dropped supplies – don’t go out there!  haven’t you ever seen a war movie?  dumb ass!  /  down to 13 men and no walkie-talkie and no food  /  more humping  /  there’s a plane – why do soldiers always yell at the plane? – it is highly unlikely they can hear you  /  Nelson is a saintly leader – no interesting character flaws (once again that Spencer Tracy “Northwest Passage” influence)  /  more humping and wading  /  they get to the site and there is – nothing!  morale = deflated balloon;  reinflation via Nelson  /  dig in and wait;  Williams dies from exhaustion, age, and being a newsman (not shot by a sniper like Ernie Pyle)  /  here come the Japs again  /  night attack – sneaky Japs sneaking;  one uses his English and impeccable American accent to kill a good guy;  Nelson sets off a flare so we can see the monkeys coming up the hill get slaughtered by Thompson machine gun fire and then a shit load of thrown grenades (which apparently the Japs had none of)  /  the cavalry arrives in the form of a paratrooper armada including gliders;  some cool glider footage  /  the twelve survivors leave in a glider hooked by a C-47 (I’ve never seen that in a war movie)  /  the end

CRITIQUE:  better than expected  /  lack of clichés, but not perfect e.g. the newsman chronicler  /  some surprises – e.g. Williams’ death  /  not a whole lot of action – a whole lot of walking  /  well acted -  EF is solid, if unspectacular  /  good score  /  dialogue is fine with some good lines  /  surprisingly little character development for a small unit movie (although we do find out that one guy is from Flat Bush)  /  no slap stick, but not too somber  /   better than “Merrill’s Marauders”

grade =  B+ 
 
Post-Script:  The movie was a big hit and got good reviews, except in England.  The British were mightily offended by the implication that the Americans won the Burma Campaign by themselves.  Churchill was one of the protestors and the film was pulled from release after one week.  It was not shown again until 1952 and with an apology added.
 
The movie was nominated for three Academy Awards:  Film Editing, Original Score, and Best Story.  One of the co-writers (Lester Cole) later was one of the Hollywood Ten.  He sure hid his communist sympathies with his patriotic script.
 
The movie was filmed at Los Angeles County Arboretum and Botanical Gardens.
 
The producer admitted he intended to copy from "Northwest Passage".
 
There are no female roles.
 
The operation most closely resembles a Chindit raid called Operation Loincloth.
 
 
 

Thursday, October 3, 2013

CLASSIC OR ANTIQUE? Operation Pacific (1951)


                “Operation Pacific” is a John Wayne WWII submarine movie released in 1951.  It was directed by George Waggner (“The Fighting Kentuckian”).  The technical adviser was Admiral Charles Lockwood, COMSUBPAC.  The movie is dedicated to the “Silent Service”.  An opening narration tells the viewers that after Pearl Harbor the subs had to carry the war effort in the Pacific.  52 subs and 3,500 submariners were lost during the war.

                The opening scene places us squarely in Old School territory.  Lt. Commander Duke (how original!) Gifford (Wayne) paddles a boat in front of a screen while someone off screen throws cups of water on him.  He rescues a group of nuns and orphans.  This was loosely based on the rescue of some refugees by the USS Crevalle after the fall of the Philippines. The kids proceed to run all over the sub, thus emphasizing the common theme of the sub as a family.   The problem is not the damned kids, it’s the damned torpedoes.  The Thunderfish fails to sink a fat juicy aircraft carrier because the torpedoes fail to explode.  We know this because we see a model of a sub in a swimming pool fire torpedoes that literally bump into the side of an aircraft carrier model.  1950s special effects – got to love them!  Speaking of Old School, one of the seamen actually says “I’m a monkey’s uncle”.

"Sorry sailor, these waters are closed"
                When the Thunderfish returns to Pearl, we enter the romance phase of the movie.  Groan!  It seems Gifford is divorced from a nurse called Mary Stuart (Patricia O’Neal).  Would you believe they divorced because he chose the service over her and their child?  (Sounds like Sgt. Stryker in "Sands of Iwo Jima".)  He chose his sub family over his real family.  However, now that he is back on shore, he wants Mary back.  And it’s not just because he misses the nookie.  Love triangle alert! Capt. Perry’s (Ward Bond) kid brother wants Mary also.  Fat chance, even Perry wants Gifford to win.  While this chemistry-less romance is exciting the females in the audience, the guys get the naval trope of Gifford bailing out his crew after a drunken brawl.


the end to every shore leave
                Back asea the Thunderfish montages its way through the Japanese fleet.  Some of this is real footage.  The Thunderfish would have won the war itself if it wasn’t for those damned torpedoes.  Queue the big set piece.  They surface when a freighter raises a white flag.  Oops, it’s a disguised warship!  Those dastardly Nips.  Actually, the U.S. used Q-Ships in the Pacific and the Japanese did not.  The Captain is wounded by machine gun fire and orders the sub to dive while he is still on deck.  This is based on the Medal of Honor actions of Howard Gilmore.  Gilmore was wounded in a duel with a gun boat which the USS Growler had rammed.  The sub dove, but when it resurfaced there was no pay back on the Japanese ship.   Duke takes command and resurfaces to ram and sink the Japanese ship.  Revenge accomplished.  Gifford in command accomplished.


"Ramming speed!"
                Enough is enough.  Back at Pearl, the crew solves the torpedo problem by dropping them on their noses.  (The idea apparently comes from a fourteen year old in the crew.)  This actually happened, but it was done by experts, not a sub crew.  Surprisingly, although everyone in the movie and in the audience is hoping for a reconciliation, Mary jilts Duke.  Oh, well – it’s back to action.

                There’s a wink-wink moment on this tour as the crew gets to watch a submarine movie.  It’s clearly “Destination Tokyo”.  The crew is bored and finds it unrealistic.  Get it?  They undergo a depth charging that is not too clicheish.  They sink a carrier because the torpedoes work now.  Then they end up in the middle of the Battle of Leyte Gulf which they win by themselves.  Not really, they get some help.


"What do you mean the wrong
actor is at the periscope?"
                As submarine movies go, “Operation Pacific” is in the middle of the pack.  As Wayne war movies go, it’s below average.  It is definitely Old School, but does avoid most of the tired clichés.  There is no going below the maximum depth scene.  No rivets pop.  There is no jettisoning debris to fake sinking.  The special effects are lame even for 1951.  I’m no fan of CGI but it beats a model in a swimming pool.  Yet, the effects were praised at the time.  Cheesy is still cheesy.  Speaking of – the music by Max Steiner is schmaltzy and I’m not just referring to the romance scenes.  There’s a laughable moment when the Japanese fleet sails into sight with stereotypical Japanese music playing.  The cinematography is fine.

                The big flaw is the plot.  The romance goes nowhere.  Throwing in a challenger for Mary’s affections is laughable.  Either Duke is going to have her or no one will.  The movie is also predictable.  Perry is dead meat as there is no chance John Wayne is going to stay subordinate to Ward Bond!  Some of the action is ridiculous.  This is especially true of the scene where they ram the disguised freighter.  Gilmore’s death was powerful enough without Hollywoodizing it.

                Classic or antique?  Definitely antique.  There are many better sub movies.  There are many better John Wayne movies.

Grade =  C
 
 

Saturday, September 28, 2013

YOU WANT SUBMARINE CLICHES? U-571 (2000)



                If you want to see every WWII submarine movie wrapped into one, you should watch “U-571” and you will be an expert on the subgenre.  Released in 2000, the screenwriters must have thought the time was right for a summary of all the clichés that had accumulated in this type of war film since the first WWII sub movie came out during the war.  It was directed by Jonathan Mostow who wrote the story and was one of the screenwriters.  The film was shot in the Mediterranean near Malta and Rome.  It did pretty well at the box office and with the American critics (we’ll talk about the British critics later).  It won the Academy Award for Sound Editing.

Cliché ahead!
                The movie begins with a crawl informing us that it is 1942 and u-boats are threatening to cut the Atlantic supply lines.  It essential that the German naval code be broken and that means stealing an Enigma machine.  One becomes available when U-571 sinks a cargo ship, but gets damaged by the subsequent depth charging and signals for a supply/repair sub.  The SOS is intercepted and a special mission is planned to take the u-boat and thus acquire an Enigma machine.  Meanwhile the sub resurfaces and the captain orders the machine-gunning of survivors from the cargo ship.  He is an evil Nazi.

                The obsolescent S-33 is given the task.  4  It is disguised to pass for the supply u-boat and a special operative named Maj. Coonan (David Keith) is added to lead the boarding party.  The captain of the sub is Lt. Commander Dahlgren (Bill Paxton).  There is a command conflict because he squelched his exec Lt. Tyler’s (Matthew McConaughey) promotion because he believes Tyler cares too much about the crew and would not be willing to sacrifice lives.  1

                The S-33 arrives at the site of U-571 on a dark, rainy night.  Coonan and his boarders are disguised as German sailors.  He takes the sonar man, the executive officer, the chief of the boat, and the radio man with him.  (You know, all the essential personnel that Dahlgren can’t afford to lose.)  The capture of the u-boat goes smoothly.  Just kidding.  The taking of the u-boat is action-packed and well-staged.  The Enigma machine (an actual one) is acquired.  Ensign Larson is killed because he wrote a letter to his new wife and had a portrait of her.  (Not just a sub cliché.)  The boarding team is headed back to the S-33 when the real supply u-boat arrives and without bothering to identify either sub, puts a torpedo into the S-33.  It blows up real good.  Tyler and the surviving boarders return to U-571 and he dives the boat as Dahlgren urges him to be a man and sacrifice his floating comrades.  3 Tough way to gain a job referral.

                Tyler and his intrepid band are able to operate the u-boat and win an underwater duel with the German boat that includes a torpedo that scrapes the side of U-571.  You don’t get any closer than that.  Tyler resurfaces to look for survivors and they pick up two – the black mess mate  7  and the German captain masquerading as an ordinary seaman.  Tyler has a little trouble adjusting to Dahlgren’s admonition that a good captain has to be a horse’s ass.  Seaman Mazzola (Erik Palladino) questions Tyler’s authority and encourages firing on an ME-109 that is scoping them out.  Don’t ask what a short range fighter is doing in the middle of the Atlantic because then you will have to ask what that German destroyer is doing out there.

                They take out the German destroyers radio antenna with an incredibly accurate deck gun shot and then dive under the ship missing the keel by inches (at least they didn’t scrape by).  Here comes the depth charging.  This is one of the best of this trope.  Intense with good effects.  We get to know all their facial features.  It’s quality plus quantity as the Germans drop about eighty explosives and at one point about twenty explode in a ten second span.  Many of them right alongside the hull.  They are forced down below “hull crush depth”, but that German engineering belies that depth gauge.  2  That doesn’t mean we don’t get leaks and rivets popping to make us wonder.  To throw off the Germans, Tyler has the corpse of Mazzola (conveniently killed by the German captain) and debris fired out of a torpedo tube.  5

                Tyler orders “Trigger” (Tom Guiry) to sacrifice himself for the good of the boat.  Now he really is a skipper and a damned good one.  When the sub resurfaces, the destroyer is chasing and straddling the sub with each salvo.  Apparently trying to sink the sub by swamping it.  There’s only one chance and it’s a one in a million bow shot with their last torpedo.  If they don’t hit their target, the Enigma machine will be lost and so will the war.  We’re here today so guess what happens.

                “U-571” is historically inaccurate in an offensive way.  The movie assigns credit for getting the Enigma machine to the U.S. Navy because an American audience would never see a movie where the heroes are not American, right?  Like “Braveheart”, “Breaker Morant”, “Cross of Iron”, “The Train”, “Schindler’s List”, etc.  At least William Wallace was Scottish.  Here are the facts.  The first naval Enigma machine was captured by the HMS Bulldog from U-110 in May, 1941.  In 1942, additional Enigma code books were taken from U-559 by HMS Petard.  Neither incident involved Americans.  If the producers thought noone would notice, they did not take into account people like me and the entire Royal Navy.  Even Prime Minister Tony Blair called it an affront to British sailors, which was an accurate statement.  The outcry caused the studio to add a postscript crediting the Bulldog and the Petard.  U-571 did exist and was sunk by a depth charge dropped by a plane.  S-33 was stationed in the Pacific.
                There are a few “based on an actual incident” fudges in the film.  There was one example of a sub torpedoing another submerged sub, but that was one incident in the entire war.  There was also one incident where a German u-boat attacked survivors from a Greek ship, but that sort of atrocity was extremely rare.

                The movie assumes the viewers do not care about historical accuracy and that they have not seen very many submarine movies.  The ridiculous pile of clichés might seem fresh to non-war movie buffs, but if you’ve seen more than a few WWII submarine movies, you’ve seen this movie.  There are also a lot of implausibilities that are grating, starting with that supply u-boat arriving in the middle of the Atlantic at just the right moment and then firing a torpedo (that it did not have because those type of subs were not armed with them) under one sub to sink another.  However, if you are of a generation that did not grow up with the Old School WWII movies, “U-571” is a nice throwback.  The acting is good.  McConaughey is solid and the supporting cast led by Harvey Keitel as the chief is fine.  Not counting Jon Bon Jovi.  The action is consistent and suspenseful.  It has a kitchen sink aspect to it.  It is technically proficient with great sound and good special effects.  The interiors are authentic looking.  The plot tries to class up the action with the theme of Tyler growing into command and the sacrifices a commander must make.

Band of Brothers - they ain't
                “U-571” is the “Memphis Belle” of submarine movies.  In both cases, you can see an entire subgenre of clichés in one viewing.  It has a record 7 out of my nine (see below).  This is okay if you don’t watch many war movies and you like your entertainment brainless with hunks (Jon Bon Jovi / Harry Connick, Jr.)  Here’s another movie of that ilk – “Fly Boys”.  If you liked two out of those three – see the other one!

grade =  C+

WWII SUBMARINE MOVIE CLICHES

1.  There are two strong personalities on board that butt heads.  Usually it’s the captain and his exec.

2.  The sub has to go below the “hull crush depth” causing leaks and rivets to pop.

3.  Someone gets left on deck when the sub has to make an emergency dive.  Usually it’s the captain who is wounded and. orders the boat to dive.

4.  The sub is sent on an emergency operation.

5.  The boat releases oil, debris, and/or a corpse to make the enemy think it has been sunk.

6.  The captain is an Ahab who is obsessed with a certain target.

7.  There is one black on board – he is a mess mate.

8.  The sub undergoes a depth charging.  Often the depth charges explode right alongside the sub, but never crush the walls of the sub.

9.  The sub lands commandoes.   Usually this results in things being blown up.

10.  The sub captain attains redemption for a previous action that haunts him.

OTHER WWII SUB MOVIES

UP PERISCOPE  (1959)   The mission is to land a frogman on a Japanese island to steal a code book.  4  The captain is not thrilled to have the commando on board  and is a by the book type.  He does not want to risk the boat by taking dangerous risks.  1  On the way there, the sub is strafed and the exec is caught on deck, wounded, and orders the boat to dive.  3  When a destroyer chases them, the captain releases diesel oil and bubbles to fool their sonar.  5  The frogman swims ashore and steals the codes.  9  There  is a black mess mate on                                    board.  7   # of clichés =  6   grade =  C

TORPEDO RUN  (1958)  A captain whose family was left in the Philippines is sent to sink a Japanese aircraft carrier.  When the carrier is spotted, a ship carrying his family is screening it.  He takes the shot anyway.  6  He and his exec disagree about how far he should go to carry out a mission.  1  The captain gets a second crack at the carrier in Tokyo Bay, but fails again.  There is a black mess mate.  7  When the carrier is spotted in the Aleutians, the sub is sent on an emergency mission to get it.  4  Number of depth chargings = 3.  # of clichés = 5  grade =  C-

WE DIVE AT DAWN  (1958)  A British sub crew is recalled early to track down a German battleship.  4  During a depth charging, they release a dead German corpse, oil, and debris.  3  They sink the battleship, but have to go ashore to get fuel and food and to blow things up.  9   One depth charging.  # of clichés =  4  grade =  B-

CRASH DIVE  (1943)   The mission is to land a commando team to destroy a Japanese Q-Ship base.  9  The confict between the captain and the exec is due to the exec putting the moves on the captain’s fiancé.  1  There is a black mess mate on board.  7  During a depth charging, the captain releases debris.  5  When the periscope gets hit, the captain stays on deck to act as the eyes of the sub.  3  Number of depth chargings = 1   # of clichés =  6    grade =  D+

HELLCATS OF THE NAVY  (1959)  The captain has to dive while a frogman is still missing.  The frogman was dating the captain’s girl, so the exec and the crew suspect ulterior motives.  The mission is to launch a commando raid on a Japanese island.  9  When they return to base, the captain gives his exec a bad evaluation because he feels he is not willing to make tough decisions.  1  The next mission is to join a wolf pack going into the Sea of Japan.  When the sub’s propellers get caught in a net, the captain goes to release them and orders the sub to dive when it is threatened.  3  Number of depth chargings = 2.  # of clichés =  4   grade =  F

RUN SILENT, RUN DEEP  (1955)  A desk captain is placed over an exec who was expecting to be promoted to command of the sub.  1  The captain is obsessed with getting a Japanese destroyer called Bungo Pete which had earlier sunk his sub.  6  A crew member is left on deck during an emergency dive.  3  There is a black mess mate.  7  During a depth charging, they release debris and bodies.  5  They sink Bungo Pete and then duel a Japanese sub.  Number of depth chargings =  2  # of clichés =  6   grade =  C

OPERATION PACIFIC  (1951)  The captain is wounded by a Q-Ship and orders a dive while sacrificing his life so John Wayne (his exec) can take command of the sub and the movie.  3  The sub has to deal with the problem of faulty torpedoes.  They work to fix this problem.  They participate in the Battle of Leyte Gulf where they are tasked to rescue downed pilots, but also get to sing some ships.  Number of depth chargings =  2.  # of clichés =  2  grade =  C

DESTINATION TOKYO  (1943)  The emergency mission is to drop off a commando team to report on weather conditions for the Doolittle Raid.  4 / 9  They sink an aircraft carrier that is launching planes to attack the Raiders.  They survive a depth charging.  8  A bow shot sinks a chasing destroyer.  # of clichés =  3  grade =  C 

SUBMARINE COMMAND (1951)  A sub skipper is torn by the loss of his previous commander at teh end of WWII in the Pacific, but gets a chance for redemption on a commando raid in the Korean War.   3  The captain is left on deck by the exec in an emergency dive.  4  The sub is part of an operation to liberate a POW camp.  7  There is a black messmate, but he has a small role.  9  The sub lands two commando teams to take out phone and radar stations.  10  The commander gets a chance to sacrifice his sub instead of a crew member.  Number of depth chargings = 1  # of cliches =  5 
grade =  C     
I know I have not included "Das Boot".  It's upcoming as one of the top ten.